It would be nice if you could hit a button and take away all the extra debt you’ve taken on. Still, unless someone invents such a button, you’re going to have to buckle down and dig your way out. When you have outstanding debts you need to clear up, you will often find yourself needing to choose between a number of options that may make your debt more manageable.
Debt restructuring and debt consolidation are two options for companies that are struggling with loans. The two are often confused. This basic overview should help those considering this type of decision.
Changing your payment structure is no small thing, so the final decision will depend on a lot of factors specific to you, your customers and your business. If you aren’t sure, or even if you’re just interested in another opinion, talk to your CFO or an outside CFO consulting group.
First, we’ll define the two. Then, we’ll compare their features and risks.
A Creditor Changes the Terms of Your Original Contract
Debt restructuring changes agreed contract terms; a settlement may include an agreed reduction in the amount owed. It involves the parties to a debt sitting down and agreeing to change the terms, normally through partial payment. In a settlement, the creditor forgives part of the debt and you pay the rest. Often this is done by agreeing to repay only a percentage of the original debt, say, 60%. Restructuring does not create a new financial instrument, rather the original one is rewritten. If it works at all, you need to be able to pay the new amount. Your creditor needs to let go of enough for the reduced payment to be realistic.
Debt restructuring is often seen as a last hope to avoid bankruptcy. It is normally done by companies facing default or other forms of debt distress. They are often out of other options. The agreement to restructure often comes when the debtholders decide it is to their advantage to get at least some of their money back if the option is shutting the business down and getting little. If a settlement succeeds and the company survives, it can also avoid lengthy, expensive court proceedings.
Consolidate Debts
Debt consolidation works by taking several different loans and merging them into one new loan. It’s just a form of refinancing to deal with debt issues that are less grave.
The first way consolidating can free up your cash flow is by merging many high-interest loans into one with a lower rate. Less of your money is being spent on interest, leaving more left over to apply to the principal. Where you go from there depends on what you want to achieve. Whether consolidation lowers monthly payments depends on the new loan’s terms. To pay the debt off sooner, the savings from a lower payment can go toward extra payments.
When it’s time to consolidate debts, a new contract is drawn up that has new terms. You will need the same documents that you provided when you applied for the loans you’re consolidating: tax returns, financial statements, sales projections. Possible lenders include banks, credit unions, the SBA and other government programs, or alternative lenders. The goal is better cash flow and easier repayment.
The Two Side by Side
Now, let’s put the two side by side to differentiate them. Consolidation is done to merge debts and make payments easier or save on interest rates. Restructuring is usually done when a business is unable to meet its current financial obligations and wants to avoid bankruptcy.
It should be obvious right away that the two choices are both a lot different and also a lot alike. When consolidating debt, you are not reducing your amount owed. When restructuring, the amount may fall if the creditor agrees.
So which one makes sense in your specific situation?
It will really depend on your company’s unique financial status: how much debt you have and what sort, the revenue coming in, company size, the industry. They will be the reason you should lean heavily on your CFO in deciding, because they understand where the company stands financially, and they understand what options exist.
It may not be as easy to choose as you think, because lenders can restrict your options. You won’t often get the chance to restructure if the company is not in serious financial straits. Consolidating can be difficult if you don’t have a long time in business, or the business has bad credit or you’ve already borrowed too much for one lender.
As you weigh the pros and cons of different ways out, you should let your CFO lead. If you do not have a CFO, look into hiring one on a part-time basis or consulting with a CFO group.
Try to start the process by setting some goals about what the outcome you want to see will look like, then talk to your CFO if you have one, and, often, have a sit-down with your creditors. Both of these tools can bring some breathing room and a chance at meeting obligations. But these debt tools will just delay the inevitable if there’s no viable underlying business plan to make it all work. A real turnaround takes work, and a strategy to increase revenue for the long-term.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that negotiates with funders for business owners. Our goal is simple: negotiate proposed settlement terms, subject to funder agreement. We are based in New York. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.







