One question we are often asked by business owners is whether a MCA funder can sue them while they are still in good standing. A proposed class action lawsuit, J.B. Plumbing and Heating of Virginia, Inc. v. Yellowstone Capital, LLC, alleges that some merchant cash advance funders have used the courts aggressively against the very small businesses that rely on their funding. This case says litigation comes after default, but depending on the agreement, a default can happen for missing one daily payment, and where a confession of judgment is enforceable, the funder may be able to get a judgment without first suing or giving advance notice. Independent counsel can assess the agreement’s default terms.
A Proposed Class Action Lawsuit
The named plaintiff in this suit is a plumbing company in Virginia that, according to the complaint, paid defendants $347,075 in interest in less than a year, plus $68,494 in ACH program fees. The company’s owner drew national attention - Bloomberg wrote an article about him, and he was invited to testify before Congress.
The complaint says the merchant cash advance industry is basically payday loans, but for businesses. Some businesses seek MCAs when traditional financing is unavailable. It is repaid by taking money out of the merchant’s checking account every day at a fixed rate, meant to be based on the merchant’s daily sales. Using new advances to cover existing payments can increase the total payment burden.
The complaint says the defendants put confessions of judgment in their contracts, where the merchants agreed in advance to let the defendants enter a judgment for any outstanding debt, so the defendants could get a quick judgment in court without first suing or giving the merchants notice. The complaint claims they’ve done this more than 6,000 times since 2012, against small businesses that allegedly didn’t make their daily payments. A complaint states allegations, not court findings. Because a confession of judgment can be entered without a lawsuit or advance notice, there may be no moment before the judgment where the merchant gets to argue about whether it really missed anything; challenging it generally means asking a court to vacate it afterward.
According to the complaint, here’s how the scheme worked: the agreements were set up to fail. According to the complaint, when the merchant’s sales dipped, the merchant would default. The complaint alleges that, at that point, Yellowstone would accelerate the whole debt, and often file the business’s confession of judgment in New York court to seize its assets. The complaint alleges that if the merchant missed just one fixed daily payment, it would have to hand over 100 percent of its receivables.
According to the suit, while Yellowstone called the transactions “merchant cash advances” to dodge state usury laws, in reality they were just loans that have to be repaid no matter what. The complaint alleges interest rates over 500 percent and ACH Program Fees that claimed to pay for a labor-intensive process, but really were fees for an automated system that didn’t require any labor. The complaint also alleges that Yellowstone’s ads always portrayed the deals as loans for small businesses, and that the agreements are substantively and procedurally unconscionable contracts, not negotiated at arm’s length, containing one-sided terms that grant the funder extraordinary power and misrepresent the nature of the transaction. The plaintiff says this violates the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act. They’re asking the court to permanently stop the defendants from collecting on what they allege are usurious agreements and to get damages for people they say have been hurt. Again, these are allegations. The filing was a proposed class action lawsuit.
The lawsuit says this kind of stuff had turned into a national epidemic, so bad that then-New York Governor Andrew Cuomo and the New York Legislature were paying attention. The lawsuit says the New York Attorney General, the Manhattan District Attorney, the New Jersey Attorney General, the Federal Trade Commission and even the United States Congress were paying attention, too. The complaint alleges that Yellowstone’s other companies operate out of New Jersey but were set up under New York law to take advantage of the state’s confession of judgment statute and post-judgment collection tools. (New York amended that statute in 2019 to generally bar confessions of judgment against debtors who live outside the state.)
Get Some Legal Advice Before You Miss a Payment
This case does not determine the position of every merchant who is current but losing sales. Where a confession of judgment is used, the time between being current and ending up with a judgment can be very short, and the business might not get a warning. Independent counsel can review any confession of judgment clause and explain the risks; contact your funder before missing a payment.
If you’ve been taking a new advance to keep up with the old ones, you might be in a debt spiral and not even know it. Staying current that way doesn’t change the math. Depending on the agreement, missing even one daily payment can lead to a default and, ultimately, a judgment.
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company. We’re not a law firm. Independent counsel hired separately can assess litigation options. Delancey Street negotiates with merchant cash advance funders to settle for less than the full amount owed, subject to the funders’ agreement. The initial consultation is free and confidential, and we can discuss possible settlement options. We also work with owners juggling stacked advances, which is exactly the kind of debt we focus on.








