The Business’s Legal Obligations to Creditors
Closing the business ends the operations but does not affect the business’s legal obligations to creditors. If you close the business and don’t address the obligations, the creditors (including SBA, the landlord and merchant cash advance provider) may be able to come after you personally if you signed a personal guaranty. If your company does file bankruptcy, it won’t discharge your guaranties. You’ll still be liable, personally, for your lease, SBA loan, merchant cash advance, and every other debt of the company that you personally guaranteed. It’s time to switch gears and focus on resolving your personal obligations.
An LLC’s shield will not protect you if you have signed a personal guaranty promising to pay an obligation if the company doesn’t. That happens all the time. Leases and merchant cash advance agreements often include personal guaranties.
Because an SBA loan can be for a significant amount, the agency often requires personal guaranties from all owners of 20% or more in the business. If the SBA steps in and pays off the lender, that loan amount becomes a federal debt with super-powers: the government can offset any tax refunds and garnish your wages. The landlord may not let you walk away from years still left on your lease, especially since the landlord knows you personally guaranteed your obligations under the lease.
A Chapter 7 bankruptcy for a business liquidates the company, sells the assets, and attempts to pay some portion of the debt to creditors. The money to pay the creditors comes from selling the assets of the company. Filing a chapter 7 bankruptcy case doesn’t change any of the personal obligations of the member(s). Unlike an individual Chapter 7 case where the filer can expect the unsecured debt to be discharged, the corporation or LLC doesn’t receive a discharge. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy of the corporation or LLC leaves owners with the problem of dealing with personal guaranties and with personal obligations for tax liabilities. Payroll taxes are a killer: the IRS can apply a “responsible person” penalty to an owner who willfully failed to pay, for all the unpaid trust fund portion of the withheld payroll taxes.
Resolve Your Personal Liability for Business Debts
A personal Chapter 7 is one option some owners consider for the worst problem, namely your personal guaranty obligations for debts of the company. A personal Chapter 7 case can discharge your obligation to pay for company debts. Most, but not all, debts are discharged in bankruptcy. An independent bankruptcy attorney can tell you whether Chapter 7 fits your personal liability for business debts. You are, though, in danger of losing money to the trustee, especially if you’ve paid creditors in the past 90 days, or transferred assets to friends or relatives. The trustee can get that money, too.
You might be able to keep the business open with an adjustment of debt plan under Chapter 11. If the business can make it, a subchapter V bankruptcy allows small businesses to develop and then implement a debt adjustment plan. To qualify, the aggregate debts (secured and unsecured) must not exceed $3,424,000. There are no competitive plans. Small business debtors have to file their repayment plans within 90 days. You as the owner of an LLC or a shareholder of a corporation may still have personal liability on guaranties.
Some creditors will settle with you for less than they are owed. It’s worth a try. Selling assets as the company closes sometimes generates enough money to make payments to resolve potential guaranties. Without a bankruptcy case, though, creditors don’t have to agree to anything. There are risks that you will receive tax liability on the forgiven amount. Cancelled debt can be excluded from income if it is discharged in bankruptcy.
Dissolution
Even if a business has already stopped operating, you can still take steps to close the business for good. That’s known as “dissolution.” Don’t forget about every state where the business entity is registered. Once it’s dissolved in the home state, each state requires paperwork to be submitted for the business to cancel its out-of-state registration, or it will continue to be subject to tax and filing requirements. The corporation must file IRS Form 966 to dissolve and a final return for that year. The IRS will keep the EIN open until all tax returns have been filed and any taxes owed paid. You can’t just walk out the door, either. If the employer is covered by the federal WARN Act and is closing a facility or conducting a mass layoff, the workers are entitled to 60 days’ advance notice of the closing or mass layoff.
One mistake you can make is delaying too long, out of a mistaken assumption that if your business was an LLC or corporation, the liability stops at the business entity. People who wait until the financial crisis is upon them seriously limit their options. Another mistake is to just double down on debt, getting one loan to pay another. It often worsens the cash flow crunch. Another is hiding or moving assets. It might feel better to hang on to important assets, but it’s not a good idea.
If your debts are discharged in bankruptcy, there’s nothing to stop you from starting a new business. Many business owners who survive bankruptcy have done exactly that. They found ways to start again, learn from the mistakes, and perhaps do it better the next time. The goal isn’t to shut your door forever. The goal is to try again, and make good decisions.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt. Based out of New York, we work with business owners in many states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.