A business pays off a secured debt in full. Then the company wants to borrow more money or a prospective acquirer runs a lien search on the company in connection with an acquisition, and the public records show that the old lender’s financing statement is still good to go. Here’s the rub: the old lender never filed a termination statement. If the business owner could call the lender and just remove the UCC lien, this would be a non-problem. But the fact remains: The lender may not even respond to your emails, phone calls or letters. So what can you do about it, and what can you recover if the lender’s silence costs you?
UCC Financing Statement
A lender with a secured interest in your assets will most likely file a UCC financing statement against those assets. It generally establishes their priority in those assets, subject to exceptions. A lender will usually file shortly after you sign a loan agreement and become bound to the terms of the deal. That filing is how the lender ”perfects” its security interest. In North Carolina, where do you file your UCC Financing Statement? The Secretary of State. But if your collateral is a fixture, the statement goes into the real estate records of the county where the property is, like Mecklenburg County’s Register of Deeds (or whatever your county calls its real estate records office).
UCC filings only stay good for five years, at which point they expire and the collateral no longer protects the lender against other secured creditors, unless the lender files a continuation to extend the expiration date. Think you’re done with a lien? When a debtor pays off a debt, the UCC does not force the secured party to automatically file a termination; the exception is consumer collateral (that is, goods purchased for or used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes). For business collateral, a secured party can choose to file a termination after payoff, but generally is not required to do so unless the debtor sends an authenticated demand. However, a debtor does have the right to demand a termination statement in writing.
A later lender, or a potential buyer doing due diligence in an M&A deal, may run a search that picks up a UCC Financing Statement that’s still in force. It might be based on obligations that have long since been paid off. In any event, the new lender or buyer usually insists on a formal termination being recorded. For example, if you’re a contractor, have tried to get a line of credit from a bank, and the bank refused your application, one of the reasons could be that there was a UCC on your primary collateral without being terminated. Lenders may simply refuse to extend credit, or require higher rates when it does so.
If the reason you went looking for new money was to get out from under merchant cash advances or other business debt, keep in mind that a new loan is not the only way out. This is where a business debt settlement company like ours steps in and negotiates with the creditors.
Within 20 Days of Receiving a Signed, Written Demand
If your lender hasn’t filed a termination, the UCC lets you send the lender a signed demand asking for the termination. Per UCC 9-513, within 20 days of receiving a signed, written demand from the debtor, the secured party must either (1) file a termination statement or (2) give you the termination statement you can file yourself, if it’s true that you don’t owe anything to the secured party and there is no commitment for the secured party to advance funds or give value. If the secured party does not do this by day 20, the UCC generally allows you to file the termination yourself, assuming you still don’t owe the secured party anything and there is no commitment to advance funds.
The same demand-and-20-day process generally applies if the creditor never got your permission to file a UCC financing statement in the first place. (That’s rarer; the loan documents almost always authorize it.)
Damages and Statutory Penalties
If you asked a lender to terminate a UCC financing statement and the lender ignored your request, you’re not out of luck. If a secured party fails to file or send a required termination statement, it is liable for damages under 9-625(b) for any loss caused by that failure. Those damages include when a failure to file or send a termination statement results in a borrower’s inability to obtain alternative financing or an increased cost of alternative financing. The secured party can also be liable for a $500 statutory penalty under 9-625(e), in addition to any damages. This matters to an owner because you could be missing out on a valuable financing opportunity because of a non-responsive secured party.
Deciding whether to go after those damages is a legal question. We are not a law firm; an independent attorney hired separately can assess whether litigation is appropriate.
For an owner who is already behind on payments, a stale filing can be the thorn in the side you least need. For a secured party, this matters because ignoring a debtor’s request to terminate a financing statement can result in payment of damages and statutory penalties. In any event, a secured party should seriously consider any request from a debtor to terminate a financing statement. And a debtor should understand its options if a financing statement needs to be terminated. If you are under that kind of pressure, a first consultation with Delancey Street is free and confidential.








