Merchant cash advances have become a lifeline for the small and mid-sized businesses that cannot get bank credit and need cash on the fly. It is an important role. But as the MCA industry is young and changing fast, fraud is an issue. An MCA is generally structured so it is not technically a loan, and repayment is not absolutely guaranteed, which can leave funders with less legal protection than lenders.
The vast majority of merchants are honest. They just need money to operate. But bad actors have been known to appear in every industry.
Telling the good from the bad takes vigilance and ingenuity.
There are a few basic types of merchant fraud that funders should know about and plan for. This article will identify some common schemes, strategies that can sniff them out, and how today’s lending software can be a great ally.
Caymus Funding
Most MCA frauds are for small dollar amounts. And there is often insufficient evidence to make it worth pursuing a lawsuit.
One case in Louisiana was an exception in which defendants took about $6.4 million from Caymus Funding and then tried to dodge repayment.
Six defendants pleaded guilty before US District Judge Jane Triche-Milazzo for wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering. Ryan P. Mullen was the alleged ring leader. The others were Zeb Sartin, Grant Menard, Lance Vallo, Dillon Arceneaux, Duane Dufrene.
Mullen and the others set up a bunch of asset-less shell companies. They fabricated documents, and Mullen posed as a broker on the shells he created.
When Caymus wired the money, the shells were closed and the group tried to keep the cash.
The fabricated documents included fake vendor accounts and bank statements, and the broker act made the deal look legitimate.
It is unclear how the defendants were caught. But after the Department of Justice stepped in, they did get punished.
This case was unusually complex and costly. But no matter how big a theft is, every funder benefits from detecting and preventing fraud.
The painful lesson is that funders should verify businesses thoroughly before funding. It’s the first step in the process.
A Few Types of Fraud
Fraud is basically deception used for financial or personal gain. So it covers a lot of ground.
A few types of fraud are mentioned below, but be on the lookout for others.
False application information is the most common MCA fraud. It may look like a simple oversight, but it can also be sinister.
Sometimes a real business with a real account number is hiding something fishy. The general idea is to secure more money than one can pay back.
For example, it’s not uncommon for a merchant to pad the revenue on an application or leave out an existing debt.
Checking a business’s finances is obvious for every funder. It is one of the very first things a funder does.
But forged bank statements allow under-qualified merchants to look like they are doing better than they are.
Everyone deserves to be given the benefit of the doubt. A small ‘fudge’ on the numbers could be a slip by a business that intends to pay it back. But fake bank statements are more likely a sign that a deal is bound for trouble.
It’s sad but bank statement templates are sold for as little as ten dollars. Fraudsters buy them and insert higher balances and healthier-looking transactions.
While consumer identity theft makes headlines and inspires feature films, commercial identity theft is less publicized.
The FTC doesn’t even collect data on commercial identity theft. It is very real, and it can be very expensive for MCA providers, which is why they shouldn’t turn a blind eye.
For example, an MCA thief may use a real business’s documents on his application and supply his own bank account. The company being used might not know that a thief is borrowing in their name.
What is phantom merchant fraud? It is creating a made-up business (or using an empty shell company like Ryan P. Mullen and his posse did), then forging every document and expecting that it will never be detected.
Any document can be forged. Fake bank and credit card statements and fake vendor accounts are tough to detect.
For example, a criminal can build a web site, rent an office and forge all his paperwork. All set up to look real. It is hard to tell the difference between the criminal who rents an office and builds a website and the one who actually sells something.
Selling a business with an outstanding MCA can raise contract and disclosure issues for independent counsel to review.
Sell and switch means the owner gets the MCA, never intending to repay.
One example is when the owner applies and meets all the requirements. The funding is timed to coincide with the business’ sale. It all looks legitimate. The new owner doesn’t know anything about the financing. Then the old owner disappears. Sell and switch fraud is hard to spot until payments stop coming.
One issue in the MCA industry is debt settlement claims that omit risks. Incomplete claims can leave owners unaware of payment obligations and collection risks.
Starting settlement negotiations does not change payment obligations or stop collection or legal action; revised terms require the funder’s agreement. Missed payments can lead to fees, collection activity, and legal action.
Due Diligence and Technology
After fraud, recovery is often difficult, so suing may not be a practical option.
What can help reduce the risk before fraud happens?
Prevention. That means due diligence and technology.
The first step to catching the fraudsters should be to collect as much information about a client as possible. Scammers depend on companies asking only a few basic details that are easy to fake.
Verifying a customer’s identity should be a multistep process that aims to confirm more details than a scammer can know how to falsify.
Confirm the business’s registration. Then cross-reference the owners’ names with watch lists like Data Merch. Look at their financials for tampering. Many funders require DecisionLogic bank verification.
These checks are like a photo ID except instead of verifying the customer’s appearance, they confirm that the business is real and actually functioning, and not a shell or stolen identity.
Auditing is also good. Analyze defaulted clients. Find what they had in common and which precautions were skipped.
Checking new applicants is not enough. Audit current clients periodically. Compare today’s numbers with what they originally submitted.
No company wants to pay for an external audit, but a fresh pair of eyes can be a good way to discover where internal procedures have slipped.
Even well-meaning employees can miss clues. Be sure to do a scheduled audit every year as well as random audits to keep staff alert.
Training staff for fraud is a bit of an art. Of course a staff should be taught how to spot a fraudster. But practice is better than theory and role-playing real life scenarios beats listening to a lecture. Each instance of fraud should be documented and the company should conduct a de-briefing session for staff when it catches one.
Fighting fraud before it happens is always worth the investment. Even when a fraudster is caught, it can be impossible to trace their assets.
Learn from other funders about the newest fraud schemes that are being attempted. Fraudsters keep looking for the weak spots to exploit. MCA funders are in a better position to deal with them if they stay connected and share their experiences.
It is very difficult to catch a fraudster without the right technology. Without a modern SaaS lending platform, workers wind up doing a lot of jobs they do not need to do.
Here are three bits of technology that can help funders identify and prevent fraud.
Cloud-based lending software combines all the information into a single system. Clients, deals, contracts and documents are all stored on one dashboard, making it easier to pinpoint any irregularities in the process.
When all the data is in one place, it is easier to make sure each deal gets the same scrutiny. If everyone is doing the same kind of due diligence, it should be easier to detect an outlier.
With an end-to-end lending platform, funders can integrate API with Decision Logic, TR CLEAR and MoneyThumb, making it easier to verify customers’ funds and identity.
Fraud detection requires heavy data analysis and mining for patterns.
While patterns are uncovered, alerts can be set up to warn staff about activity that requires additional scrutiny. Setting alert thresholds and automated reports are a must. Software works tirelessly and frees staff up for other duties.
Automated fraud detection software can flag a fake or altered digital document.
Modern software can spot patterns that human eyes may miss. AI finds problems early.
Fraud is part of life in an imperfect world.
Alternative finance will always attract scam artists who are out to grab the money and run.
The trick is to arm your team with the tools and the training it needs to stop fraud from happening.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: review your cash flow and negotiate proposed settlement terms with funders, subject to their agreement. We are based in New York. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








