One bizarre extrajudicial maneuver is hurting businesses big and small in California. A disgruntled person - often calling themselves a sovereign citizen - can file fake documents, UCC 1 and JL 1 forms, on the public Secretary of State UCC database.
Each state has a central office where UCC filings are maintained, usually the Secretary of State. This article covers the California office only.
A UCC 1 is a public notice that a creditor has a security interest in some of a debtor’s assets, like inventory, equipment, or receivables. A lender might give a car dealer a loan and use the car dealer’s vehicle inventory as collateral (security). Filing generally perfects that interest and sets priority in the event that the debtor defaults or declares bankruptcy.
California law says a UCC 1 can be filed only if the debtor authorizes it, generally in a record the debtor has signed; signing a security agreement counts as that authorization for the collateral it describes. There is no place on the form for the debtor to agree to the filing. That consent is typically found in the written agreement between the parties.
A judgment creditor may record a JL 1 notice of judgment lien in the UCC database. Unlike most states, California’s SOS allows this. Unlike the UCC 1 (consensual), the JL 1 is non-consensual. The JL 1 is a notice telling the public the creditor won in court and holds a judgment signed by the court.
A wrongful filing can affect a business quite badly. Filing a false UCC 1 implies that assets have already been used as collateral, or that a business is engaging in shady secured transactions, thereby affecting the business’s credit. A false JL 1 implies that the business has lost a lawsuit.
The law doesn’t allow any of this. Under Cal. Com. Code section 9509 the UCC 1 needs the debtor’s authorization, and the JL 1 needs an actual judgment. But the law alone doesn’t stop fraud, because the filing office generally doesn’t verify consent, and a nonconsensual filer can file as easily as anyone.
The SOS generally doesn’t have the power to block fake UCC 1 filings because its UCC office’s role is administrative and ministerial (see Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, section 22600 et seq.). It generally doesn’t check that the forms are consented to, only that they are complete. Similarly it doesn’t verify if a form was based on a real judgment.
Under the UCC, a filing the debtor never authorized is generally ineffective; it has no legal effect. But it’s still sitting on the public database, telling anyone searching that you owe the filer money. Independent counsel can explain the available remedies.
Filing Review and Correction Options
If you believe a UCC 1 or JL 1 notice is false, independent counsel can review the filing and related records. As the secured party of record, a filer can generally terminate its own filing whether or not it is the real secured party.
If the filer does not file or send a termination statement within 20 days after an authenticated demand to terminate a filing the debtor never authorized, the debtor can generally file a UCC 3 “Financing Statement Amendment” to amend the UCC 1 filing. On the UCC 3 form there are boxes to mark the “termination” of the UCC 1 filing. But the UCC 3 does not delete the UCC 1 filing, it merely adds the UCC 3 to the UCC 1’s record. A person researching your name will still see the UCC 1 and will still have to decide that it was wrongful. The SOS website will still list you as a debtor.
A UCC 5 “Information Statement” records a claim that a filing is inaccurate or wrongful. There are boxes to check to say that the UCC 1 is incorrect, was wrongfully filed, or was filed by someone who is not entitled to. There is a free-text box to explain the reason in more detail. But like the UCC 3, the UCC 1 stays on the record with the debtor’s name.
A false JL 1 is trickier. Apart from a court order, generally the only person who can remove a JL 1 from the database is the judgment creditor (or someone it authorizes). Without a court order, there is generally no form the debtor can file. If the filer refuses, the debtor’s remaining option is generally to go to court.
Possible Court Remedies for Disputed Filings
The UCC 3 and UCC 5 “band-aids” do not provide a court-ordered expungement of the bogus filing, and they don’t get the business any money for the harm the filing caused. Independent counsel can assess whether court action is appropriate.
A false public record claiming someone owes money can be defamatory on its face, so a claim of defamation per se and trade libel might be possible. The way the filing process was used may also matter. One potentially relevant law is Cal. Code Civ. Proc. section 765.010. That code section is a bar against knowingly filing a false lien or encumbrance against another person, or getting someone else to do it, to harass them. Potential remedies include expungement, statutory penalties, costs and attorneys’ fees, subject to applicable law and court findings. Independent counsel can determine which claims, if any, fit the facts.
Suing costs money and time, but a successful suit can get the filing expunged and may recover damages and litigation costs.
The California legislature is aware of these false filings, and Assembly Bill 501 was introduced as a proposal to raise the penalty in Code of Civil Procedure section 765.040 from $5,000 to $15,000, and to allow the debtor to recover triple the court fees spent trying to get the UCC 1 removed. As of January 15, 2026, the bill was waiting for the Appropriations Committee and had not become law.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: review your finances and negotiate proposed settlement terms with funders. Based out of New York, we can discuss whether our services are available in your state. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








