Say you had to shut down your business, and you defaulted on a Small Business Administration (SBA) loan that you had personally guaranteed. Are you stuck paying off the entire balance, or could you reach a settlement? Everybody wants to pay their bills but when catastrophe strikes and you have to throw in the towel on your business, you just don’t always have the means to get everybody paid off. If it is an SBA loan, the SBA has a program for borrowers who want to stay out of bankruptcy and make a good-faith settlement with the lender, called an Offer in Compromise.
Most people want to pay as little as they possibly can. So how little can you settle for? It’s never as easy as it seems and you want to be careful how you negotiate. The short answer is, about as much as the lender could recover from you in a forced collection. Here’s how the lender thinks about it.
If an SBA borrower defaults, the business that received the loan will most often be liquidated first so as much of the balance as possible is recovered to satisfy the creditors. The lender will then pursue the guarantors, usually the owner who signed and sometimes family or friends of the owner that also guaranteed the loan. The guarantors are “joint and several,” which means that there is only one balance, but each guarantor is liable for the entire balance. So, if there are five guarantors, it does not mean that each guarantor is responsible for 20%. The SBA will pursue whoever they believe will be the easiest to collect from, or whoever has the most resources.
Factors That Lenders Will Take into Account
There are lots of factors that lenders will take into account when deciding what you are worth to them, but there are four big ones: the value of your assets, your earning capacity, your cooperation and character, and the cost of collection. Assets are pretty self-explanatory. Total your big assets (equity in your house, cash and cash equivalents, bank accounts, cars, investment properties, etc.). Subtract the secured debt attached to them. That’s your current equity. Certain laws protect assets from creditors, including the homestead exemption in your state, certain protections for retirement savings and college funds, and a cap on garnishing wages.
Nonetheless, do not assume you can pay $0 if your assets are not accessible. An Offer in Compromise is a privilege, not a right; you are negotiating in good faith with the bank to save the cost and hassle of either a bankruptcy or a lawsuit. For example, if you live in Texas, your home may be homestead protected, and you are living in a $500,000 home with no mortgage, but you owe the bank $250,000. Sure, the bank may not be able to take your home, but they’re unlikely to walk away from $250,000 for pennies on the dollar when it’s clear you could afford to pay the balance. If your debt was $800,000 and you did not have enough available equity to refinance the balance, then you can probably settle for a much lower figure.
There is always a future earning capacity component to an SBA offer in compromise. But the future earning capacity can be a bit of a challenge to calculate. The lender will look at your present employment and earnings, past history of earnings, age and health. They will then make a rough guess at what they could collect from you through something like a wage garnishment. Keep in mind that state laws may cap or restrict the amount of money that can be garnished from you, particularly if you are the head of the household and have a large number of dependents. Garnishment is calculated after mandatory deductions, such as Social Security, Medicare, and federal income tax, but before voluntary deductions, such as health insurance and your 401k. Garnishment is time consuming and costs the lender money, and is generally slow to collect, so you can often offer much less on a lump sum than garnishment would bring in. To them, cash in hand now is worth more.
Working with the lender and demonstrating your character may be the best single factor in a settlement. And, not only is this helpful in getting a settlement at all, but it may be helpful in reducing the amount you pay. During the liquidation analysis and during the financial review the lender will need your cooperation and participation. For example, you will probably need to have physical collateral appraised and you will need to deliver financial statements. During these periods you should demonstrate your willingness and desire to help them get the most money possible - this will carry a lot of weight during the negotiation. Many owners who did nothing and ignored the lender until they got sued had a much tougher time getting a better offer.
Finally, there is the cost of collection, the amount the creditor has to pay to try to collect through legal action. That can be anything from sending you a default notice in the mail to taking your home in foreclosure. It all costs them money, and if the collection process stretches out for a long time, it really costs them money. This is why they may be willing to settle for less than the entire debt now as opposed to pursuing the money through the courts for years.
Document Everything
Paperwork matters, too. The SBA doesn’t require much paperwork, only two standard forms: SBA Form 770 and Form 1150, and two years of tax returns, but you should include a lot more if you want a chance of being approved. Document every number, fact, or figure you present to the lender with a third-party document. If you note a mortgage balance on the Form 770 personal financial statement, attach your most recent mortgage statement so they can see how you got the number. And most importantly, write a compelling hardship letter.
So, can a defaulted business loan be restructured? If it’s an SBA loan, the Offer in Compromise gives you a way to settle it in good faith. How much it will cost to get this settlement will depend on the amount of assets you have, your ability to earn money in the future, your cooperation, and how much it would cost the lender to take collection action against you. Consider it the good-faith negotiation that it is, be proactive rather than reactive, document everything, and if you can muster a lump sum, consider offering it.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we can help business owners in many states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








