You closed down your business, and didn’t pay all the bills. Can you clean up the debts, or are they just gone?
When a business winds down and closes down, it often does so owing money to creditors. In California, the law provides some broad protection for shareholders and directors, as well as protection for new companies. It’s like a wall for shareholders and directors, generally keeping out the creditors of the old company, subject to exceptions such as personal guarantees.
Like a wall, though, the California law has some large holes - exceptions that can let creditors reach owners or new companies.
A corporation or LLC is a separate legal entity. It has its own debts, and it owns its own property. It is a legal fiction, but California courts treat it as very real. So as a general rule, if a creditor gave the corporation or LLC credit, only the corporation or LLC is liable. If the corporation or LLC ceases business, the debt generally remains owed by the company, but with no assets left it may be difficult for a creditor to collect. Foreclosure by secured creditors, assignment for benefit of creditors, or business closure can affect collection options, but do not necessarily end them.
But an unpaid creditor will not always just write off the account. Some collection companies would close the file at this point, but a wise creditor looks for answers. Do you own another corporation, LLC or proprietorship? Are you or a company you own still in the same kind of business? What did you do for your old company’s creditors in the wind-up? What happened to the old company’s assets, including the inventory the old company never paid for? Keep records and bring creditor requests or court papers to independent counsel promptly so you can respond on time.
How can the creditors get that information from you? If creditors really want to get information, they may actually file a lawsuit against a closed business because a lawsuit opens up discovery. Even if nobody answers that suit, the creditors might take a default judgment against the company, and then take you, the owner, to a judgment debtor’s exam - under which you would be asked to produce records, and to testify about the old company’s affairs. In practice, the mere allegation of alter ego and the service of an order, may prompt negotiations for a voluntary payment, i.e., a settlement.
Alter Ego
The theory these folks are trying to invoke is called alter ego. The California court that decided this has defined this theory to mean that it requires a couple of things: (1) such a unity of interest and ownership between the corporation and the person or business controlling it that the separate personalities no longer exist, and (2) that refusal to disregard the corporation would sanction a fraud or promote injustice. The biggest plus that a creditor will have is if they can show mixing of assets. For example, where the new company has sold inventory purchased by the old company, but never paid for, or where the owner of the old company took a cash withdrawal out of the old company when it closed down, and used it to start up the new one, those facts can be evidence of both unity of interest and injustice.
Other warning signs of unity of interest and injustice include payment of the old company’s debts out of the owner’s or another company’s bank account; common officers or employees; common customers or suppliers; funds withdrawn from the company accounts not accounted for or paid out as a ‘bonus’. That’s why this is a fact to pay attention to: if a creditor can point to this about an owner, an old debt that seemed gone can become something to negotiate again.
Now picture the file a creditor might build on you. The creditor’s files show you stiffed it for months, then your phones got disconnected and the company’s status was suspended for not paying taxes. Then, when the creditor did some more checking, it found out that the old company transferred most of its inventory to the new company, that the new company had the same officers, and that the new company was two blocks away. It also found out that you received a $50,000 ‘severance package’ from the old company when you closed it, and that you started the new company with that money. Facts like those can give a creditor a strong claim.
Claims Against the New Company and the Owner
A creditor can sue the new company and the owner on the grounds of “alter ego” and “fraudulent transfer of assets” to avoid paying the creditors. If no judgment has been issued yet, the creditor can amend the complaint in the same lawsuit. If a judgment has been issued, the creditor can file a new lawsuit against the owner and the new company. California law may also allow a court to add the new company and owner directly onto an old judgment (i.e., without the new suit), but only in limited circumstances. One example of this is a case where an association lost a suit, then filed a document for a new entity with the same board of directors and the same type of business, immediately after the judgment was issued, and the new entity was added to the judgment.
In the above example, it’s pretty obvious, but in many other cases, it’s not so clear. But if you shut down your old business and opened a new one, any creditor who decides to look into it will have questions. They may seek a settlement of the old debt from the new business, but recovery depends on the facts and any agreement. This is usually done through a lawsuit. So an old debt that you thought was gone may come back, and you could end up settling on it. Even if nothing was transferred, independent counsel can review any remaining debts, guarantees and personal liability.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: negotiate proposed settlement terms with your creditors. We are based in New York. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








