Covid-19 has created significant liquidity and cash flow issues for businesses across the economy. In today’s unsettled financial environment, many small business owners find they can no longer meet loan repayment terms. Crain’s Content Studio asked attorney and CPA Robert J. Malatak to talk about options after a borrower defaults. Robert Malatak is a partner at Windels Marx Lane & Mittendorf, LLP, whose practice covers bankruptcy, loan reworking, workouts, and collecting court awards from uncooperative debtors. He explained how each side views a loan in distress, and the steps the small-business owner can take now to resolve the issues before they become bigger.
The pandemic has had an especially heavy impact on small-business borrowers in retail and hospitality, and on commercial real estate. But beyond them, the effects were more far-reaching because interconnections among sectors mean that pain suffered by some translates into pain for many. Although some business borrowers started to struggle before the pandemic, it was their final straw. A loan may have started out as healthy, then the pandemic hit and the borrower could not keep up with payments. Malatak explained that many small business owners found they could not maintain bank covenants to keep their loans in good standing. These challenges do not have to lead to bankruptcy.
Malatak said it is important to consult an attorney with background in both creditor and debtor practices. Small business owners frequently withhold information from their lender. But lenders often find out about borrowers’ problems through public channels or their financial statements. Borrowers must disclose problems in order for banks to know the full picture. Lenders often become distrustful when borrowers fail to make full disclosure. A bank may come down hard when it loses trust in a borrower. Without full information, the lender may feel it has no choice but to take drastic action against a borrower. That leaves the borrower in a far worse position. The best scenario for both the borrower and the lender is to work together to create a plan to find the best path forward.
Options for Borrowers and Lenders
Insolvency means that a borrower’s liabilities exceed its assets or it cannot make the principal and interest payments as they mature. Options may include negotiating a workout or discussing bankruptcy with independent counsel. Ignoring the problem or failing to pay eventually invites lawsuits. Ignoring the situation also can lead to involuntary bankruptcy, something few would prefer. The most responsible path is for the business owner to consult advisers and contact the lender as soon as the borrower realizes it is falling behind, and go into the process with its eyes open. When lenders and borrowers work together, they can make good-faith efforts to come up with a fair solution for both parties. They may be able to reach a number of possible solutions: 1) a loan modification, 2) refinancing with a third party, 3) the lender accepting a deed in lieu of foreclosure or 4) the borrower’s selling the property to a third party.
It is easier for lender and borrower to come to terms if there is only one entity at the table. When several lenders are involved, each lender is going to fight to secure the maximum cash they can. When a loan is oversecured or fully secured, which means that the collateral is worth more than the loan, lenders are more amenable to negotiation. If the value of the collateral and cash flow is not enough to secure a reworked deal, the lender might require pledging additional collateral as part of the new deal to reach agreement. Requests for new guarantors or personal guarantees and collateral raise risks that independent counsel can review.
When weighing refinancing, borrowers may find that existing banking relationships affect the terms offered. Current lenders sometimes may be able to offer better terms than a new lender. However, other lenders might extend more generous terms to obtain the business. The borrower should compare the terms of the present loan with the terms the new lender may offer, to determine which is the better option. A qualified financial professional can help compare staying with the original lender against other options. That comparison depends on the borrower’s cash flow. Terms also will play a role in its final decision.
The lender needs to know if collateral and guarantees still provide enough security. A lender will want to know if the business is viable long-term. If a borrower can convince them it can rebuild its business, lenders might be receptive to reworking the loan. The borrower should take some time to review the loan documents. Banks want performing loans. Lenders are trying to be flexible, and may be willing to rework loans, but they also have rules of their own to follow. Moreover, some lenders - as much as they would like to help borrowers - might be hindered by laws and regulations. Regulations were written before the pandemic.
Bankruptcy May Offer a Better Solution
For certain debtors, bankruptcy may offer a better solution than a workout. Businesses may opt for Chapter 7, Chapter 11, or Subchapter 5 of Chapter 11, a subcategory created to enable small businesses to reorganize more quickly and cheaply. The borrower has to analyze the advantages and disadvantages of each route and which is optimal in its situation. The many small businesses right now reeling from pandemic effects may be able to benefit from Subchapter 5 of Chapter 11 of the bankruptcy code. If the borrower pursues a workout or refinancing instead, it is key to only agree to terms that can actually be met. If the borrower defaults on the modification or refinancing terms, the lender will not likely provide another workout or refinancing. Whether it is a workout, new financing, or bankruptcy, the borrower needs to bring in competent legal counsel.
Judgment Creditor
If the lender wins a judgment against the debtor, the lender can utilize all legal collection tools available to a judgment creditor. A judgment creditor needs precise, prompt legal counsel to maximize the value of its judgment, or the rights and remedies available to collect the judgment might be waived or subordinated to more aggressive creditors. Substantial collection experience and skill is often necessary to avoid wasting time and money, or losing judgment collection rights due to inattention. Certain opportunities for collecting on a judgment can be short-lived. Collection depends on available assets, competing claims and applicable law. But collecting on a judgment does not always happen quickly. Patience is a requirement when collecting a judgment from an uncooperative debtor. Attorneys skilled in debt collection and litigation can maximize the creditor’s chances of recovering any judgment, sometimes in full.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners negotiate with funders. Our goal is simple: review your finances and negotiate proposed settlement terms with funders. Based out of New York, we can discuss whether our services are available in your state. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








