”I never dealt with that individual. Why the hell would he put a UCC-1 on my business?” UCC filings scare business owners and other entrepreneurs. In Rhode Island, anyone with an internet connection can file a UCC financing statement claiming a security interest in your company’s property, even if the filer has never done business with your company. Acceptance of a filing does not establish authorization, and the state does not verify whether the filer actually has a valid security interest. The Secretary of State’s office has no discretion to reject a filing because it looks fraudulent.
Why would someone do that? Sometimes the point is to hurt your reputation with a public record. Sometimes it’s plain harassment. And sometimes it’s to cause trouble when you try to borrow money. Filing a bogus UCC financing statement can make lenders wary. At worst, a bogus lien can keep you from getting secured financing at all. When you’re an entrepreneur whose company could be in trouble, time is everything. Here are five UCC filing issues that independent counsel can explain.
The first way is to keep watch. You can’t stop someone from filing a bogus statement, but you can check the UCC database on a regular basis. The Secretary of State hosts it on its website, so open a browser window and go there. A corporate monitoring service can also do the checking for you. Independent counsel can review a suspicious filing.
Independent counsel can explain possible responses to a disputed filing. The second way is a UCC-5 information statement, which a debtor can file with the Secretary of State to record a dispute about a filing. It won’t make the fake financing statement unenforceable. It informs anyone searching the UCC database that the financing statement is disputed. All the UCC-5 does is create notice to the public. So it doesn’t automatically get removed, but it does get flagged, so the dispute is visible if anyone looks. The flag on the bogus financing statement might make a difference when a creditor is deciding whether to make a loan to the business. The information statement will have to say that it is an information statement, the file number for the financing statement it’s responding to, and the reason that the filer thinks the statement was wrongfully filed. If the financing statement covered real estate, it also must state that fact, identify the real estate, and (if applicable) say that it was filed in the real estate records, give the name of the record owner if it was not the debtor, and the date and time or book and page that it was filed.
The third way is a UCC-3 termination statement, which, when filed with proper authorization, makes the financing statement ineffective. But a debtor generally can’t file one right away. Questions about a filing’s accuracy are separate from negotiations over the underlying balance. We can separately discuss the underlying balance with the funder. The filer can then send you a termination statement to file, or file one with the Secretary of State themselves. After 20 days pass without a response to the debtor’s demand, Article 9 generally allows the debtor to file the UCC-3 termination statement itself, if the other statutory conditions are met. In that situation, the debtor doesn’t need the filer’s authorization to file the UCC-3 termination statement: Article 9 allows the debtor to file it, as long as the termination statement indicates that the debtor authorized it. A properly authorized UCC-3 makes the unauthorized financing statement ineffective.
There’s a catch, though. The bogus filing remains in the system for at least a year even if a termination statement is filed. The law acknowledges it can’t provide a totally effective solution to the problem of misuses of public records. For a business that needs financing now, a year will feel like an eternity. That is where the fourth way comes in. Companies concerned with earlier removal of a bogus filing should explore with their counsel obtaining injunctive relief from the courts.
The fifth way is a claim for money against the filer. Article 9 says a person is liable for any loss caused by a failure to comply with it, so if an unauthorized filing causes a loss, the debtor may be able to sue the filer for the loss. Statutory damages may also apply. Under Article 9, statutory damages are $500 each time a person files a record naming a debtor without the debtor’s authority. And, again, $500 statutory damages are available if a person fails to file or send a termination statement after receipt of an authenticated demand. Modest sums, maybe, but that is a serious deterrent to making a fake filing.
So when do you need an attorney? The honest answer is it depends. It depends on how you decide to fight back, and it depends on the filer. It depends on how bad the filer hurt you, and whether you want to sue the filer for money. It’s a matter of following a process. A lawyer isn’t required to file a UCC-5 or a UCC-3. But if the filer’s actions have damaged you, you’re better off hiring a lawyer right away. And getting the court’s order, the fourth way, has legal consequences if you get it wrong. If you want to sue the filer for money, you need an attorney. These cases are not as easy, and you’ll want help from a competent business lawyer. Even at the demand stage, a lawyer can help. A demand letter written by a lawyer is more likely to be taken seriously. But any situation where the filer won’t cooperate, or the fictitious filing won’t go away, should be looked at by a lawyer.
Rhode Island Is Behind
It’s also worth knowing that Rhode Island is behind here. At least 31 states have passed laws meant to make it less likely their filing offices accept a bogus statement in the first place. Until that changes, the job of spotting and fighting a bogus filing generally falls on the business owner. If you find a fake financing statement against your company, independent counsel can review it.








