Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Debt Settlement and its Effect on Your Credit Report

You’re drowning in debt. The bills keep piling up, and you can barely tread water. Debt settlement sounds like a lifeline – but is it? Let’s dive into the murky depths of how settling your debts could impact your credit report and score.

What is Debt Settlement?

Debt settlement is the process of negotiating with your creditors to pay off a portion of what you owe – for a reduced lump sum. It’s an alternative to bankruptcy, but one with its own set of risks and rewards.You essentially tell your lenders: “Look, I can’t afford the full amount, but I can give you X% right now to close out the debt.” If they agree, you pay the settled amount, and the debt is considered “paid” or “settled.”It’s not a magic wand though. Debt settlement comes with a catch – a potentially nasty one for your credit report.

How Debt Settlement Affects Your Credit Report

When you settle a debt, it leaves a permanent mark on your credit report. That settled account will be listed, along with crucial details:

  • The account’s original balance
  • The amount you paid to settle
  • The remaining unpaid portion that was written off by the creditor

It’s a double-edged sword. On one hand, you’ve resolved the debt and avoided further delinquencies. On the other, you’ve proven unable (or unwilling) to fully repay what you originally agreed to.The settled status lingers for 7 years from the date you first fell behind on payments. It’s a constant reminder to future lenders that you didn’t hold up your end of the bargain.

The Credit Score Impact

A debt settlement is better than not paying at all, but it’s still a negative mark that can significantly ding your credit score – especially if you have good credit to begin with.Just how much? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but expect your score to take a hit of anywhere from 45 to 125 points, depending on:

  • Your current credit score range
  • The size of the settled debt
  • How many other negative items you have
  • Whether you brought the account current before settling

The higher your score, the harder you may fall after settling a debt. And settling multiple accounts in a short period? That multiplies the damage.To illustrate the potential impact, let’s look at a hypothetical scenario:

Credit Score Before Settlement Debt Settled Estimated Score Drop
780 (Excellent) $5,000 -100 to -150 points
720 (Good) $5,000 -60 to -110 points
680 (Average) $5,000 -45 to -85 points

As you can see, the same $5,000 settled debt could mean a 150-point plummet for someone with excellent credit – enough to push them into “fair” territory. The impact lessens for lower starting scores, but it’s still a significant blow.Of course, these are just estimates. Your real score impact depends on the calculation methods used by the different credit scoring models.

The Debt Settlement Process – A Catch-22?

Here’s where debt settlement gets tricky: to convince creditors to accept a settlement, you generally have to go into default first. Yes, you read that right – you have to stop making payments.It’s the “rock and a hard place” of debt settlement. Creditors are unlikely to negotiate if you’re still paying something each month. But every missed payment further damages your credit score and report.So in pursuing a settlement, you’re forced to:

  1. Miss payments until accounts become delinquent
  2. Negotiate settlements
  3. Watch your credit score plummet from all the lates and delinquencies

It’s a Catch-22 that can make the debt hole even deeper before you find a way out. And it gets worse – settled debts may be considered taxable income by the IRS if over $600.No wonder consumer advocates urge extreme caution when considering debt settlement!

Debt Settlement vs. Bankruptcy – Which is Worse?

Debt settlement and bankruptcy both allow you to resolve debts for less than what you owe. So which path is least harmful to your credit?In most cases, bankruptcy is more damaging initially but provides a faster path to recovery. Debt settlement lingers longer as a negative trade line.Let’s compare their typical credit score impacts side-by-side:

Event Estimated Credit Score Impact
Bankruptcy Filing -130 to -240 points
Debt Settlement (single account) -45 to -125 points
Debt Settlement (multiple accounts) -130 to -350 points

As you can see, settling multiple accounts in a short timeframe can be as damaging as bankruptcy in the near-term. And debt settlement’s effects last longer on your credit report.The advantage of bankruptcy is that it provides an eventual “fresh start” by clearing all debts. Settled debts remain for 7 years from first delinquency.Of course, bankruptcy has its own major downsides – a potentially complex legal process, loss of assets, long-term public record, etc. Debt settlement avoids those pitfalls if done properly.So which path is right for you? It depends on your specific financial situation and goals. Consulting professionals is highly recommended before making such a major decision.

Minimizing the Credit Damage

If you do opt for debt settlement, there are ways to potentially minimize the damage to your credit report and score:

  1. Settle while accounts are current, if possible. This avoids racking up delinquencies first.
  2. Try to settle one large debt vs. multiple smaller ones. One settled trade line is better than many.
  3. Ask creditors to report “Paid as Agreed” or use neutral codes. This can lessen the negative impact.
  4. Pay settled debts promptly and in full. Lingering partial payments can further hurt your score.
  5. Work on improving other credit factors. Payment history is most important, but improving credit utilization, credit mix, and new credit can offset some damage.
  6. Add positive tradelines through self-lender loans or secured credit cards. This introduces good new credit to your file.
  7. Be patient and persistent. Credit can rebound significantly in 1-2 years with good habits.

None of these are a magic cure-all. But they can help put you in a better position to start rebuilding your credit after debt settlement.

When Debt Settlement Makes Sense

Given the potential credit score damage, debt settlement isn’t an easy choice. It’s best reserved for situations where you’re truly unable to repay your debts in full through other means.If any of the following apply, debt settlement may be worth considering as a last resort:

  • You’re judgment proof with no assets to seize
  • Your income is so low that creditors are unlikely to ever get paid
  • You’ve experienced a job loss, medical issue, or other hardship
  • Bankruptcy is not an option due to timing or other reasons

The risks of debt settlement are still present. But if you have no other way to resolve your debts, the credit score damage may be the lesser of two evils compared to perpetual delinquency.Just be sure to carefully weigh all options and potential consequences first. Your credit is too important to gamble with lightly.

The Bottom Line: Proceed with Caution

Debt settlement is a powerful tool that can eliminate what you owe – but at a serious cost to your credit report and score. While better than not paying at all, it should only be used as an absolute last resort.If you do decide to settle, go into it with open eyes. Understand the potential short and long-term credit impacts. Take steps to minimize the damage where possible. And have a solid plan to start rebuilding your credit once the dust settles.

Delancey Street is here for you

Our team is available always to help you. Regardless of whether you need advice, or just want to run a scenario by us. We take pride in the fact our team loves working with our clients - and truly cares about their financial and mental wellbeing.

"Super fast, and super courteous, Delancey Street is amazing"
$500,000 MCA Restructured Over 3 Years
"Thanks for helping me in literally 24 hours"
$250,000 SBA Loan Offer in Compromise
"Great choice for business owners who need a trustworthy partner"
$350,000 MCA Restructured Over 2 Years

In The Media

Delancey Street CEO discusses ways to reward employees
Delancey Street CEO discusses the benefits of franchising on Forbes.
Delancey Street CEO discusses management on AMEX.
Best Michigan Business Debt Counselors

Best Michigan Business Debt Counselors Navigating the choppy waters of…

Best Michigan Financial Advisors

Best Michigan Financial Advisors Choosing the Right Financial Advisor in…

Best Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers

Best Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Navigating the choppy waters of bankruptcy…

Best Michigan Turnaround Management Firms

Best Michigan Turnaround Management Firms Introduction Navigating financial distress and…

Best Kansas Turnaround Management Firms

Best Kansas Turnaround Management Firms Introduction to Turnaround Management Firms…

Delancey Street simply gets it. You're talking to experts.
Steven Norris
Get Help Today

Ready To Get Started?

If you have questions, feel free to shoot us an email, or fill out our live chat.

Schedule Consultation