Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Gusto vs. Paychex: An In-Depth ComparisonYou’re a small business owner, looking for the best payroll and HR solution. Two names keep popping up – Gusto, and Paychex. But which one is right for you?In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the features, pricing, pros and cons of both Gusto and Paychex. By the end, you’ll have all the information you need to make an informed decision for your business. Let’s get started!Payroll ProcessingWhen it comes to the core function of any payroll system – actually paying your employees – both Gusto and Paychex deliver. But there are some key differences to be aware of.With Gusto, payroll is a breeze. The interface is intuitive and user-friendly, allowing you to run payroll in just a few clicks. Gusto automatically calculates and files federal, state, and local taxes for you. Direct deposit is standard, or you can print checks yourself – the choice is yours.Paychex also offers full-service payroll, but the user experience isn’t quite as streamlined as Gusto’s. The interface feels a bit dated and can be harder to navigate. Like Gusto, Paychex will handle your payroll taxes – but you’ll pay extra for that service on their lower-tier plans.One unique payroll feature Gusto offers is their “AutoPilot” mode. If your payroll doesn’t change much from cycle to cycle, you can put it on AutoPilot and Gusto will run it automatically. Paychex doesn’t have an equivalent feature.So while both platforms will get the job done, Gusto comes out ahead for its superior user experience and included tax filing services on all plans. The AutoPilot feature is a nice bonus for businesses with straightforward payroll needs.

Feature Gusto Paychex
Automated payroll
Direct deposit
Print own checks
Tax filing included On higher plans
AutoPilot mode

Employee BenefitsOffering a competitive benefits package is crucial for attracting and retaining top talent. But managing benefits administration can be a huge headache. Let’s see how Gusto and Paychex stack up.Gusto really shines when it comes to benefits. Their platform makes it easy to set up and manage health insurance, 401(k) plans, HSAs, FSAs, and more. Gusto partners with leading providers like Blue Cross Blue Shield, Humana, and Guideline 401(k).Employees can self-onboard and make elections entirely online. And because benefits integrate seamlessly with payroll, deductions are always accurate and up to date. Gusto even has licensed benefits advisors on staff to help you build the perfect package for your team.Paychex offers benefits administration too, but it’s not as robust as Gusto’s. Health insurance is only available through a referral to a third-party broker. 401(k) plans are available, but the investment options are limited compared to Gusto’s partner Guideline.The employee experience on Paychex isn’t as user-friendly either. Onboarding and elections often require paper forms, which can lead to errors and delays. And the integration between benefits and payroll isn’t as seamless, so there’s more manual work required to keep everything in sync.For businesses looking to offer a top-notch benefits package with minimal administrative overhead, Gusto is the clear winner. The wide range of integrated options and user-friendly platform sets them apart.

HR ToolsPayroll and benefits are just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to HR. From hiring and onboarding to time tracking and compliance, there’s a lot to stay on top of. Both Gusto and Paychex offer tools to help – but the depth and quality of those tools varies.Gusto’s HR toolkit is thoughtfully designed and covers all the bases. You can post jobs, track applicants, and onboard new hires paperlessly. Time-off requests and approvals are handled effortlessly online. Plus, Gusto provides a library of customizable policy templates, so you don’t have to start from scratch.When it comes to compliance, Gusto has your back. They’ll automatically file new hire reports with the state and send mandatory notices like the new hire pamphlet. You can even store digital I-9s and W-4s securely in Gusto. And the built-in safeguards help prevent costly mistakes, like paying overtime to exempt employees.Paychex’s HR offerings feel more fragmented in comparison. Many of the tools, like time tracking and learning management, are separate add-ons rather than being integrated into the core platform. And the interface for things like PTO requests isn’t as user-friendly as Gusto’s.On the compliance front, Paychex will file new hire reports – but they don’t provide as much proactive guidance as Gusto does. There aren’t built-in safeguards against common compliance pitfalls. And while you can store some employee documents in Paychex, the functionality is limited.For an all-in-one HR solution that’s intuitively designed and compliance-focused, Gusto comes out ahead. The seamless integration and attention to detail make managing HR tasks a lot easier.

- -
Feature Gusto Paychex
Hiring & onboarding Limited
PTO management Add-on
Policy templates
New hire reporting
I-9 & W-4 storage Partial
Compliance safeguards

Ease of UseAt the end of the day, even the most feature-rich software is only useful if it’s easy to use. When you’re running a business, the last thing you want is to waste time struggling with clunky, confusing tools.This is where Gusto really stands out. Their platform is beautifully designed and a joy to use. The interface is clean, modern, and intuitive. Everything is exactly where you’d expect it to be, and complex tasks are broken down into simple steps.Gusto’s employee-facing tools are just as impressive. The self-service portal and mobile app make it easy for employees to access pay stubs, request time off, update personal info, and more. The user experience is so good that employees might actually enjoy using HR software for once!In contrast, Paychex’s platform feels outdated and cumbersome. The navigation is less intuitive, and certain tasks require more clicks than they should. The visual design is cluttered and can be overwhelming at first glance.The employee self-service tools on Paychex are functional but not particularly user-friendly. The mobile app has limited features and lower ratings compared to Gusto’s app. Employees may need more hand-holding to complete basic tasks.When it comes to ease of use, Gusto is the clear frontrunner. The thoughtfully designed interface and delightful user experience set them apart. With Gusto, you’ll spend less time wrestling with software and more time growing your business.

Customer ServiceNo matter how good the software is, questions and issues will inevitably come up. When they do, having reliable customer support can make all the difference.Gusto offers customer service that’s in a league of its own. Their support team is US-based and available by phone, email, and live chat. The representatives are knowledgeable, friendly, and genuinely helpful. They’ll take the time to understand your issue and work with you until it’s fully resolved.But Gusto goes above and beyond just being reactive. They also provide proactive support in the form of a dedicated account manager. This point person gets to know your business and is always available to answer questions, share best practices, and help you get the most out of the platform.Paychex’s customer service is a bit more hit or miss. While they offer phone and chat support, the quality of assistance can vary widely. Some representatives are helpful and efficient, while others seem undertrained and struggle to resolve complex issues.Email support on Paychex is notoriously slow, with response times of 24-48 hours being common. That can be frustrating when you have a time-sensitive question or problem. And there’s no dedicated account manager, so you’ll likely talk to a different rep each time you call in.For businesses that value high-quality, reliable customer service, Gusto is the way to go. The combination of knowledgeable reps, fast response times, and proactive support from a dedicated account manager is hard to beat.

Feature Gusto Paychex
US-based support team
Phone & chat support
Knowledgeable, helpful reps Varies
Fast email response times
Dedicated account manager

PricingOf course, all the features and quality support in the world don’t matter if the price tag is out of reach. Let’s take a look at how Gusto and Paychex stack up in terms of cost.Gusto’s pricing is simple, transparent, and affordable. They offer three tiers of service: Core, Complete, and Concierge. The base fee starts at just $39/month plus $6/month per person. That includes full-service payroll, benefits administration, and basic HR tools.As you move up to the higher tiers, you unlock advanced features like time tracking, PTO management, and dedicated support. But even the top-tier Concierge plan is only $149/month plus $12/month per person – a fraction of what some other providers charge.Paychex’s pricing is a bit more opaque and varies widely based on your specific needs. Their plans start at $59/month plus $4/month per employee for basic payroll. But that doesn’t include tax filing services, which will cost you extra.If you want to add on HR tools or benefits administration, the costs can quickly add up. Many of the features that are included with Gusto require a separate (and pricey) module on Paychex. And getting a straight answer on pricing often requires sitting through a lengthy sales call.When it comes to bang for your buck, Gusto is hard to beat. Their transparent, affordable pricing and robust feature set make them an excellent value for small businesses. Paychex may be a fit for larger companies with more complex needs, but for most SMBs, Gusto offers more for less.

The Bottom LineSo, where does all this leave us? When it comes to choosing between Gusto and Paychex, there are a few key factors to consider.For businesses that prioritize ease of use, robust features, and great customer service, Gusto is the clear winner. Their platform is a joy to use, with thoughtfully designed tools that cover the full spectrum of HR needs. And their support team is second to none, with knowledgeable reps and dedicated account managers who proactively help you succeed.Gusto’s transparent, affordable pricing is the icing on the cake. You get a ton of bang for your buck, with plans starting at just $39/month plus $6/month per person. And because payroll and benefits are fully integrated, you won’t waste time juggling multiple systems.Paychex may still be a fit for larger businesses with highly complex needs. Their platform is more customizable (albeit harder to use), and they offer some niche features that Gusto doesn’t. But for the vast majority of small and medium businesses, Gusto offers everything you need and more.Of course, every business is unique, and there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. The best way to see if Gusto is right for you is to take advantage of their free trial. In just a few minutes, you can get set up and see for yourself how easy and powerful their platform is.

- -

Get Debt Relief Today

Delancey Street is here for you

Our team is available always to help you. Regardless of whether you need advice, or just want to run a scenario by us. We take pride in the fact our team loves working with our clients - and truly cares about their financial and mental wellbeing.

"Super fast, and super courteous, Delancey Street is amazing"
$500,000 MCA Restructured Over 3 Years
"Thanks for helping me in literally 24 hours"
$250,000 SBA Loan Offer in Compromise
"Great choice for business owners who need a trustworthy partner"
$350,000 MCA Restructured Over 2 Years

In The Media

Delancey Street CEO discusses ways to reward employees
Delancey Street CEO discusses the benefits of franchising on Forbes.
Delancey Street CEO discusses management on AMEX.
Got a UCC Lien from a Business Loan? How to Remove It Once Repaid

  Got a UCC Lien from a Business Loan? How…

California Debt Relief Lawyers

California Debt Relief Lawyers: Your Guide to Financial Freedom Navigating…

California Business Debt Settlement

Comprehensive Guide to California Business Debt Settlement Navigating the landscape…

New York Student Debt Relief Lawyers

New York Student Debt Relief Lawyers: Your Comprehensive Guide Student…

Arkansas Debt Consolidation

Arkansas Debt Consolidation: Your Path to Financial Freedom Navigating the…

Delancey Street simply gets it. You're talking to experts.
Steven Norris
Get Help Today

Ready To Get Started?

If you have questions, feel free to shoot us an email, or fill out our live chat.

Schedule Consultation