Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

What Happens if You Don’t Pay a Debt Settlement?

Dealing with debt can be super stressful – and things can get even more complicated if you’ve agreed to a debt settlement but can’t follow through on the payments. Let’s break it down and look at what could happen next.

Missing Debt Settlement Payments – The Basics

So you’ve negotiated with your creditors or a debt settlement company to pay off a portion of what you owe. Maybe it was credit card debt, medical bills, or even back taxes causing you trouble. The settlement agreement laid out a payment plan to get that debt off your back for less than the full amount.But life happens – you lose your job, have a medical emergency, or something else comes up that makes those debt settlement payments impossible. What gives? Well, missing those agreed-upon payments can have some not-so-fun consequences:

- -
  • The debt settlement becomes void – Kiss that discounted payoff amount goodbye. Your creditors can then go after you for the full, original debt amount.
  • Collection efforts resume – With the deal off, your creditors will likely start aggressive collection tactics again like harassing calls, letters, and potentially lawsuits.
  • Credit score impact – That settled debt gets reaged and shows up as delinquent on your credit reports, tanking your credit score.
  • Tax implications – You may owe taxes on any forgiven debt from the original settlement.

So in a nutshell – failing to pay on a debt settlement means you’re back at square one, with the full debt load and creditors breathing down your neck. Not an ideal situation at all.

What to Do If You Can’t Pay a Debt Settlement

Okay, so missing debt settlement payments is bad news – but what can you actually do about it? A few options to consider:

Renegotiate the Terms

As soon as you realize you’ll have trouble making those payments, the smart move is to go back to your creditors or debt settlement company. See if they’ll work with you to modify the payment plan to something you can actually afford. They may be willing to extend the timeline or lower the monthly amounts to avoid losing the whole deal.

- -

Request a Hardship Plan

Many creditors have hardship programs that can provide temporary relief if you’ve had a job loss, medical issue, or other major financial disruption. This could allow you to pause payments or pay a reduced amount until you get back on your feet.

Look Into Bankruptcy

For some, bankruptcy may be the best path forward if debts are just completely unmanageable. Chapter 7 bankruptcy can wipe out many types of unsecured debts entirely, while Chapter 13 allows you to reorganize debts into a multi-year repayment plan. It’s not an easy choice, but it can provide a fresh start.The key is being proactive and communicating with your creditors or debt settlement company. Ghosting them and missing payments is never a good strategy – it’ll just make the situation worse in the long run.

Debt Settlement Pros and Cons to Consider

Before we get into the nitty-gritty details, it’s worth stepping back and weighing the pros and cons of debt settlement as a debt relief strategy:Pros of Debt Settlement

- -
  • Pay less than the full debt amount owed
  • Resolve debts faster than making minimum payments
  • One monthly payment instead of juggling multiple bills
  • Stops debt collector harassment (at least temporarily)

Cons of Debt Settlement

  • Credit score damage from missed payments
  • Tax liability on forgiven debt amounts
  • Risk of being sued by creditors if they refuse to settle
  • Upfront fees charged by many debt settlement companies

Debt settlement can be a viable option for getting out of debt without bankruptcy – but it’s not a magic cure-all. You have to be very disciplined in setting aside funds for the lump sum payments required.

Potential Legal Troubles from Unpaid Debt Settlements

One of the biggest risks of not paying a debt settlement is the creditor taking you to court. And if they get a judgment against you, buckle up – because things could get bumpy:

- -
  • Wage garnishment – Creditors can legally garnish up to 25% of your disposable earnings from each paycheck until the debt is paid.
  • Bank account levies – They may be able to seize funds directly from your checking or savings accounts.
  • Property liens – Tax debts and certain other types can result in liens being placed on your home, car, or other assets.
  • Asset seizure – As a last resort, creditors can potentially have your personal belongings seized and sold to satisfy the judgment.

The lesson? Don’t ignore debt settlement agreements or any subsequent court judgments. Creditors have a lot of legal muscle to compel payment, even if it means garnishing your hard-earned wages or going after your assets.

Debt Settlement Company Risks

Using a debt settlement company to negotiate with creditors on your behalf can seem appealing. But be wary – there are some potential pitfalls to watch for:

  • Upfront fees before any debt is settled
  • Pushy sales tactics and unrealistic promises
  • Lack of transparency about the process
  • Failure to properly educate you on tax implications
  • Not all creditors will agree to settle

Do your homework and read reviews before signing up with any debt settlement firm. The best companies will have low upfront costs, clearly explain the risks, and show a solid track record of delivering results for clients.

Debt Settlement Laws and Regulations

There are federal laws like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act that debt settlement companies must follow. These rules prohibit deceptive practices and give you certain rights as a consumer.Many states also have their own debt settlement laws and licensing requirements that companies must comply with. For example, Massachusetts caps the fees debt settlers can charge and requires a surety bond.If you feel a debt settlement company has violated any laws or regulations, you can file complaints with the Federal Trade CommissionConsumer Financial Protection Bureau, and your state’s consumer protection office.

Debt Settlement Defenses and Strategies

Even if you’ve missed debt settlement payments, you may still have some potential defenses and strategies to try:

  • Statute of limitations – In many states, creditors only have a limited number of years to sue over unpaid debts before the debt is essentially uncollectible.
  • Prove the debt – Creditors must be able to validate the debt amount and their legal claim to it. Demand proof if you dispute the debt.
  • Negotiate a lump sum – See if your creditor will accept a one-time lump sum payment for a portion of the balance as a final settlement.
  • File an answer in court – If sued, file a formal answer with the court within the required timeframe to assert your defenses.
  • Claim exemptions – Certain assets like Social Security income may be exempt from garnishment or seizure, depending on state laws.

The key is knowing your rights and not just rolling over if a creditor gets aggressive over an unpaid debt settlement. But getting professional legal help is highly advisable to properly assert any defenses.

Debt Settlement vs Bankruptcy – Which is Better?

For many struggling with unmanageable debt, the choice comes down to debt settlement or bankruptcy. There are pros and cons to each approach:

Debt Settlement Pros Over Bankruptcy

  • Avoid the stigma and long-term credit impact of bankruptcy
  • Only some debts are settled, others remain intact
  • No court proceedings or involvement of a bankruptcy trustee
  • Debts can be re-settled if payments are missed

Bankruptcy Pros Over Debt Settlement

  • Debts are discharged completely, providing a true fresh start
  • Automatic stay stops all debt collection efforts
  • Certain assets may be exempt from liquidation
  • Court-approved process with strict rules for creditors

Bankruptcy has serious long-term credit and financial ramifications, so it shouldn’t be entered into lightly. But for those who can’t qualify for or afford a debt settlement plan, it may be the better option.

Tax Implications of Settled Debt

Here’s an important consideration many overlook with debt settlements – you may owe taxes on any amount of debt that gets forgiven or canceled by your creditors.Why? Well, the IRS considers forgiven debt as taxable income. So if you settled $20,000 worth of credit card debt by paying just $10,000 – you may have to claim that extra $10,000 as income when filing taxes.There are some exceptions, like if you were legally insolvent when the debt was settled. But in general, expect to receive a 1099-C form from your creditor for any forgiven amount over $600. Not the most fun surprise come tax season.The lesson? Make sure to set aside funds to cover any potential tax liability from debt settlement. Or look into options like using non-exempt assets or retirement funds to pay off the full balance instead.

When Debt Settlement Makes Sense

Despite the risks, debt settlement can be a viable path out of debt for the right person in the right situation. It may be worth considering if:

  • You have a lump sum of funds available to negotiate a settlement
  • Your credit is already badly damaged from missed payments
  • Bankruptcy is not an option you want to pursue
  • Your main goal is reducing your total debt load quickly

But it’s not a magic pill – debt settlement requires diligence, discipline, and careful consideration of the potential drawbacks. For many, credit counseling or debt consolidation may be better first options to explore.

Getting Professional Help with Debt

Dealing with debt issues and potential settlements can be incredibly stressful and confusing. That’s why it’s often wise to get professional legal help to understand all your options and rights.Look for a qualified debt settlement attorney or reputable credit counseling agency in your area.

Having an experienced professional on your side can help you make smart decisions and avoid costly mistakes when it comes to dealing with creditors.

The Bottom Line on Unpaid Debt Settlements

At the end of the day, not paying a debt settlement you’ve agreed to can have major negative consequences – from restarting collection efforts to potential court judgments and garnished wages. It’s not a situation anyone wants to find themselves in.The smart move if you can’t make those payments? Be proactive in communicating with your creditors or debt settlement company. See if you can renegotiate the terms, request a hardship plan, or potentially look into bankruptcy as a last resort.

Get Debt Relief Today

Delancey Street is here for you

Our team is available always to help you. Regardless of whether you need advice, or just want to run a scenario by us. We take pride in the fact our team loves working with our clients - and truly cares about their financial and mental wellbeing.

"Super fast, and super courteous, Delancey Street is amazing"
$500,000 MCA Restructured Over 3 Years
"Thanks for helping me in literally 24 hours"
$250,000 SBA Loan Offer in Compromise
"Great choice for business owners who need a trustworthy partner"
$350,000 MCA Restructured Over 2 Years

In The Media

Delancey Street CEO discusses ways to reward employees
Delancey Street CEO discusses the benefits of franchising on Forbes.
Delancey Street CEO discusses management on AMEX.
Best Michigan Business Debt Counselors

Best Michigan Business Debt Counselors Navigating the choppy waters of…

Best Michigan Financial Advisors

Best Michigan Financial Advisors Choosing the Right Financial Advisor in…

Best Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers

Best Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyers Navigating the choppy waters of bankruptcy…

Best Michigan Turnaround Management Firms

Best Michigan Turnaround Management Firms Introduction Navigating financial distress and…

Best Kansas Turnaround Management Firms

Best Kansas Turnaround Management Firms Introduction to Turnaround Management Firms…

Delancey Street simply gets it. You're talking to experts.
Steven Norris
Get Help Today

Ready To Get Started?

If you have questions, feel free to shoot us an email, or fill out our live chat.

Schedule Consultation