Avoid Bankruptcy by Settling Its Debt
A business can often avoid bankruptcy by settling its debt, but only if enough creditors agree and the business can actually pay what it promises. A settlement is a private contract. No creditor has to accept one, and a creditor that refuses can keep suing, levying accounts, and enforcing liens. Out-of-court deals tend to work for a business with a handful of unsecured creditors, enough cash or new money to fund lump sums or a payment plan, and no large tax debts. They tend to fail when one secured lender, the IRS, or a single aggressive creditor holds enough leverage to block the deal. The honest answer turns on who the creditors are, what they would get if the business were liquidated, and whether the owner has signed personal guarantees.
Creditors accept a workout because it is better than what they will receive in a liquidation. An unsecured supplier or lender of an insolvent company may receive nothing if the business goes out of business or files a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. So, an agreement to pay a lesser amount may be more attractive than having a judgment against a shell company. However, this logic makes a holdout creditor very powerful. In a workout, the business will need to bargain separately with each creditor. A holdout creditor is not bound by the agreement reached by other creditors. If the workout requires all of the major creditors to accept an offer, then the refusal of even one holdout will jeopardize the entire transaction and money paid to the other creditors may be wasted.
Resolve the Holdout Problem
Chapter 11 bankruptcy is able to resolve the holdout problem, unlike a private agreement. In Chapter 11 bankruptcy, creditors are divided into classes. A class of creditors accepts a bankruptcy plan if two-thirds in dollar amount and a majority in number of creditors in the class voting accept the plan. If the bankruptcy plan is confirmed, then non-accepting members of the class are bound by the bankruptcy plan. The bankruptcy plan can be confirmed despite objections by some creditors as long as at least one class of impaired (non-insider) creditors accepts the plan, and the plan is fair. Filing for Chapter 11 triggers an automatic stay, halting further collection activity. The filing fees for Chapter 11 are $1,167, plus an administrative fee of $571, before professional fees are incurred.
Subchapter V of Chapter 11
A more affordable alternative in small business cases is Subchapter V of Chapter 11. The Subchapter V debt limit affects the choice between settling and filing a case, and therefore is included here. As of April 1, 2025, the debt limit for cases under the subchapter is $3,424,000, with at least half of the debt arising from business activities. It is not available for “single asset” real estate debtors. Congress permitted the expiration of the original debt limit of $7.5 million on June 21, 2024. In September 2026 the U.S. House and the U.S. Senate approved H.R. 7730, which would make the $7.5 million limit permanent for cases filed after the bill became law. The bill awaits the signature of the President, as of early October 2026. In Subchapter V, only the debtor can propose a plan, and the plan must be filed within 90 days. A trustee is appointed in every Subchapter V case and a disclosure statement is usually not needed.
Personally Guaranteed the Debt of a Company
Personal Guarantees: Is A Business Settlement A Personal Settlement? If a business owner has personally guaranteed the debt of a company, a release of the guarantor must be set out in writing in a settlement between the lender and the company. Otherwise, the settlement will not release the business owner from the debt. In June 2024, the US Supreme Court issued a 5-4 decision in Harrington v Purdue Pharma that a bankruptcy plan in a Chapter 11 reorganization cannot release a claim against a non-debtor without the consent of the affected creditors. A reorganization of a debtor company will likely not be able to release the debt of a guarantor against a creditor’s wishes. Business owners who have personally guaranteed company debt may have to have simultaneous settlements of both the company and the guarantor or file personal bankruptcy.
Taxable as Income
In most cases, the forgiven debt amount is taxable as income. Exceptions to this rule exist. Amounts of discharged debt received in bankruptcy are excluded entirely. The primary exclusion of amounts of discharged debt outside of bankruptcy is the exclusion for being insolvent. The exclusion is reported on IRS Form 982. The exclusion is only to the extent of liabilities in excess of the fair market value of the assets of the company immediately before the debt is cancelled. For example, if a company’s liabilities are $400,000 and the fair market value of its assets is $300,000, the company is insolvent by $100,000. If the company negotiates to settle its debt and has $130,000 forgiven, the company can exclude $100,000 from gross income, and $30,000 is taxable income.
The exclusion reduces certain tax attributes of the company, such as net operating loss carryover and tax basis in property. For a partnership or multi-member limited liability company (taxed as a partnership), the determination of insolvency is made at the partner level. For an S corporation, the determination of insolvency is made at the corporate level.
Payments Made in Settlement Can Be Clawed Back
If the business subsequently enters bankruptcy any payments made in settlement can be clawed back. Section 547 of the Bankruptcy Code allows the bankruptcy trustee to claw back payments on old debts made within 90 days before the bankruptcy (or within a year before the bankruptcy, if the creditor is an insider such as an owner or relative of the debtor), and the debtor is presumed to have been insolvent during the 90 days before the bankruptcy. The payment must have resulted in the creditor receiving more than it would have received if the debtor had gone directly into Chapter 7 bankruptcy. No clawback will occur for a business debtor for payments of less than $8,575, in the aggregate, to a creditor. Section 548 of the Bankruptcy Code also allows the bankruptcy trustee to claw back any transfer of less than reasonably equivalent value, if made within two years of the bankruptcy and the debtor was insolvent. A workout which prefers some creditors or insiders and then fails can be partially clawed back.
The Trust Fund Recovery Penalty
The payroll tax. I.R.C. § 6672 allows the IRS to impose the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (“the Penalty”) on any person responsible for withholding payroll taxes who willfully fails to remit them to the IRS. The Penalty equals the whole unpaid trust fund taxes. The IRS treats payment of vendors or other creditors rather than the withheld taxes as willful, as does payment of net wages without payment of withholding. Two or more officers or owners may be liable.
Advance Debt Often Has More Settlement Room
Merchant cash advance debt often has more settlement room than owners assume, because some advance contracts face legal challenge. In January 2025, the New York Attorney General announced a $1.065 billion judgment and settlement with Yellowstone Capital. The state had alleged that the company’s advances were really loans with effective rates as high as 820%, with fixed daily debits taken regardless of the business’s revenue. The settlement cancelled $534,552,724 owed by more than 18,000 businesses, required $16.1 million paid immediately, and called for vacating judgments and removing liens. Yellowstone admitted no wrongdoing. Owners considering paid help should know that the FTC’s advance-fee ban, which bars fees until a debt is actually settled and paid, is written around consumers’ telemarketed debt relief, so a business may not get the same protection.








