If you think you can work it out, then do so. For example, with a few creditors, you might talk to each individually. On the other hand, if the company is more than a small business or if there are many creditors to deal with, restructuring (especially if it involves bank debt or secured debt) is not a casual or informal process. Bankruptcy is a restructuring process that solves the problem that there are multiple creditors with different agendas. Every business in debt has specific circumstances - financial health, ongoing business strategy, relationships with creditors, etc. Your creditors may or may not allow a restructure of terms, and future cash flow can also affect the decision to file. Negotiation and Chapter 11 are two ways of achieving the same goal: to reduce and restructure debts so that a business can survive.
Chapter 11
As soon as a Chapter 11 case is filed, a company can take advantage of certain restructuring tools not available outside of bankruptcy. One of the most powerful of these tools is the ability to propose a plan of reorganization that is binding on creditors who vote to reject the plan (cram down) if certain requirements are met. Non-bankrupt companies trying to negotiate with their banks, for example, don’t have the ability to cram down lenders. Chapter 11 also provides an automatic stay during which the debtor company can attempt a reorganization free from creditor collection attempts, including multiple lawsuits. This means a company gets a breathing spell to fix or change its business. With Chapter 11, the management usually stays in control.
The plan is the document that spells out how the company will treat its debts. Typically, the court holds a hearing after which the court approves or rejects the plan. Absent certain conditions, confirmation is only given to a plan that has been accepted by the creditors, who vote on the plan. A class is deemed to accept a plan if two-thirds of the dollar amount and more than half the number of claims vote for the plan. Confirmation of a plan generally discharges debts arising before confirmation.
Owners of corporations do not place their personal assets at risk by filing a corporate bankruptcy. With a sole proprietorship, of course, the distinction between business and personal is blurred. The individual is responsible for the debts of the business.
Chapter 11 can be costly. It requires a debtor to make timely and ongoing filings and follow other requirements that take time and effort to comply with. Costs for Chapter 11 bankruptcy include a $1,167 filing fee, a $571 administrative fee for a total of $1,738 at filing. Afterwards a quarterly fee to the U.S. trustee is owed, varying between $325 to $30,000 depending on how much was disbursed during the quarter. Other costs are legal expenses (including lawyers and financial advisors).
A debtor needs to consider the costs and business distraction of Chapter 11 weighed against the benefits the Chapter 11 case is expected to provide. If those benefits don’t materialize and a Chapter 11 is not successful, it may be necessary to consider conversion to a Chapter 7 case which will result in the liquidation of the business or to dismiss the case. If management doesn’t appear to be doing a good job, the court may appoint an independent trustee.
Subchapter V of Chapter 11
The Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019 (“SBRA”) created Subchapter V of Chapter 11, which is designed to provide small businesses with a more streamlined and cheaper reorganization. Subchapter V limits the businesses that can file by setting a total debt threshold of $3,424,000. A trustee is appointed in Subchapter V. On the other hand, under Subchapter V, no quarterly fees are charged to the U.S. trustee. Under this chapter, only the debtor may propose a plan, which is due within 90 days of filing. The judge will hold a status conference within 60 days of filing, so as to keep the process moving along. In Subchapter V, if there are dissenting classes of creditors, then the plan must require that all projected disposable income of the debtor is paid for 3 years, or up to 5 years if the court so determines. However, there is no such rule if the plan is fully consensual. Congress passed H.R. 7730 on September 28, 2026, which would raise the Subchapter V debt limit to $7.5 million permanently. It has not yet been signed by the President and would only apply to cases filed after the law becomes effective.
Outside Bankruptcy
Out of court, there are disadvantages. For example, you may not get all the creditors to agree. There is no automatic stay outside bankruptcy. Even if you successfully negotiate with one or more creditors, other creditors can continue suing, which undermines the ability to settle. Also, if you settle with creditors and then wind up having to file bankruptcy later, any payments you make to those creditors within 90 days before the bankruptcy filing can be clawed back as preferences, unless they are for ordinary-course payments. If the creditor is an insider, the clawback period is one year.
Taxes are another concern: forgiven debt is usually income even if no Form 1099-C is issued. However, canceled debt in bankruptcy is not income. Outside bankruptcy, canceled debt is excluded from income up to the amount you’re insolvent. Either exclusion means filing Form 982. Even if the cancellation of debt is excluded from income, you still may have to reduce tax attributes, such as net operating losses (NOLs), which will reduce your tax benefit.
Which choice is best for you depends on those specific circumstances. A company with expensive debt but enough money to pay necessary operating expenses might want to try working with creditors on their own before filing bankruptcy. If you can’t catch up on loan payments, and don’t think you’ll be able to, Chapter 11 may be one option to look at. This is something to discuss with your bankruptcy attorney, given your particular circumstances.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we work with business owners in many states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








