If your business is struggling under debt, it’s good to know which debts can’t be settled with the creditor. Some are very hard to negotiate, like payroll taxes, other federal taxes, SBA and EIDL loans, plus debts from fraud or fines. That comes down to two key reasons. First, the federal government has a huge array of super-powers with which to collect, such as seizing tax refunds, garnishing wages, or even filing a lawsuit to recover. Second, these debts are more likely to hit you as a personal obligation if your business goes under, even if the debt is in the company’s name.
Withheld Payroll Taxes
Unpaid payroll taxes are the toughest debts of all. The IRS can charge any owner, officer, manager or employee who’s responsible for paying these taxes. If you’re in charge of paying withheld payroll taxes and the IRS finds you “willfully” ignored that duty, it can charge you a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty of 100% of unpaid amount. Even letting one creditor get paid ahead of the IRS could be enough for the agency to impose this penalty on you. Their idea of “willful” is extremely broad. IRS might not need to prove you had evil intent, even a bad motive. In bankruptcy, taxes you have to withhold — such as employees’ income tax and their share of FICA — are treated as a priority debt, however old.
It may be possible to settle other tax debt. If you make an Offer in Compromise, saying that you can’t pay your entire debt, you might succeed. Just making an offer requires a $205 non-refundable processing fee. If you settle in a lump-sum, you must submit 20% of the offer up-front. To qualify, the employer must have made every federal tax deposit for this quarter and the two before it. The IRS generally has 10 years to collect past federal tax assessments, from the date the agency makes it. Income taxes are treated as priority debts in bankruptcy, if the return was due, with extensions, within 3 years before you file.
SBA Disaster Loans, EIDL or Traditional Ones
SBA Loans fall in this category, too. Most of them require a personal guarantee. So you will owe this debt even if your business closes. Once you start missing payments, most lenders call the loan delinquent and contact you asking for immediate payment. Failure to make payments for 3 or 4 months may be considered a default. If you default, the creditor may jump on this, seize the collateral and sell it, then if there’s any remaining debt unpaid, grab your guarantors’ personal assets, then seek repayment from the Small Business Administration, if it guaranteed the loan. The SBA typically gives notice before they take it to Treasury collections. That notice might be a 60-day demand letter. That gives you the chance to make an “Offer in Compromise” or pay the debt in full before the matter goes to Treasury collections. Once that account reaches Treasury, you can expect even more aggressive attempts at collection. They can garnish wages or take tax refunds or other government benefits to make you pay. They can also sue you.
The SBA generally will accept an “Offer in Compromise” only if you can prove you can’t repay within a reasonable amount of time and your business no longer operates, has liquidated assets and spent the proceeds on the debt. That means SBA won’t likely accept an OIC for active businesses.
For COVID-19 EIDL loans, over $25,000, the creditor needs collateral, and over $200,000 a personal guarantee. SBA may send delinquent EIDL’s to the Treasury Offset Program after 120 days. Once the loan has entered the Treasury Cross-Servicing, the SBA can no longer assist you. Once Treasury has the debt, it can offset payments, garnish wages, refer the debt to credit bureaus, and refer it to the Justice Department for action. If you’re behind on an SBA disaster loan, contacting SBA may get you a repayment plan, but the agency has lots of options if you fail to take advantage of them.
When you hear that bankruptcy will wipe out all of your debts, that’s not entirely true. Bankruptcy doesn’t erase everything for an individual. Money gotten by fraud or a false written financial statement, a fine or penalty owed to the government, or willful and malicious injury to person or property are debts that could survive bankruptcy, though fraud and injury debts won’t last unless the creditor asks the court to make it so. Sometimes SBA loan debt may be discharged in bankruptcy, and this is determined by the specific type of bankruptcy you file.
Before Negotiating for Settlement
The first thing you should do is get in touch with your lender and be honest about what’s going on. They may let you defer payments, make interest-only payments, or even lengthen the term. You should also review expenses and cash flow forecast. Look for costs you can cut. A business debt consolidation loan might take several high-interest debts and roll them into a single new loan, ideally at better rates and terms. You may want a CPA or business attorney to review your finances and structure an offer in compromise. You can find a financial business mentor who may be able to help, perhaps through SCORE, which offers free mentors.
Of all your bills, unpaid payroll taxes carry the most personal risk, so talk to a CPA or tax professional about how to handle them. If you find the 60-day delinquent notice in your mail, be sure to respond before the debt goes to Treasury.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we help business owners in many states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








