Say you are a business owner who just opened a letter from a lender you have never heard of. The letter says a vendor you buy from pledged its receivables, the vendor has defaulted, and you now must pay the lender instead of the vendor under UCC 9-406. (Yes, the law really lets lenders collect receivables directly from a borrower’s customers without any court action.) You were not expected to know about the Uniform Commercial Code or section 9-406. The notice raises a bunch of questions.
Here is why it happens. Lenders often like a borrower’s accounts receivable for collateral because it is only one step away from cash, unlike other property that must be insured, stored, marketed and sold. When the loan turns bad and the lender decides to declare a default, it can send a notice to the borrower’s customers demanding they make their payments to the lender, all without ever going to court. Here are five points to understand; bring a notice like this to independent counsel promptly.
First: “Take a deep breath.” That is our advice if your vendor’s lender hits you with a UCC 9-406 letter and tells you to send your payments to them instead of to your vendor. Then remember that, generally, your vendor pledging its receivables and the lender’s notice do not change the amount you owe, the terms of the account, or your rights under it, like a discount for returned merchandise or prompt payment. The assignment does not make you pay the lender more than you would have owed the vendor in the first place. Figure out precisely what you owe your vendor. Do you in fact owe money? If so, how much and when was the payment due?
Second, think twice before you lean on the vendor. If you got one of those notices, your first reaction was probably to call the vendor. There is no provision in the UCC that says you either must or must not call. Some owners call to make sure the vendor knows the check might not be coming, to see if the vendor still looks stable or if they should be looking for a new supplier, or just to ask if the notice is legitimate. But here is the catch: if the vendor tells you the notice was sent in error and you keep paying the vendor anyway, the risk of having to pay twice is generally on you. A proper notice generally works whether the vendor approves or not. Once the proper notice has been given, paying the vendor no longer counts as paying your debt. What if you paid the vendor anyway, only to find out that you now owe the lender the same money again?
Third, proof of assignment helps explain the lender’s claim. If you ask, the UCC says the lender has to give you ”reasonable proof” that the assignment actually took place. That usually means showing evidence that the vendor gave the lender a security interest and that the receivable you’re responsible for is included in that. Read the notice carefully. Section 9-406 says a notice is ineffective if it doesn’t reasonably describe the rights being assigned. It also says it is ineffective, at your option, if it tells you to pay the lender less than the full amount of a payment that you were supposed to make to the vendor. Keep the notice and any related records. If you’re not sure a notice is adequate, bring it to independent counsel promptly and respond on time.
Fourth, know what happens if the lender does not respond to a request for proof. Under 9-406(c), if the lender does not provide requested proof, you can generally discharge the debt by paying the vendor even though you received the notice, and paying the lender generally still works if the assignment is genuine. But if the lender never actually received the assignment, paying a random third party (like a fraudster) does not release your debt. Also remember: the notice does not alter the payment terms. If a payment deadline approaches before the lender responds, seek prompt guidance from independent counsel.
Fifth, seek independent counsel promptly, especially when the facts are messy; seeking help does not extend payment deadlines. A major supplier or a company with multiple product lines might have multiple secured lenders, each with a security interest in its accounts receivable. A secured lender’s interest is not a secret. You can sometimes figure out who they are by doing a quick online search with the Secretary of State’s office. The official commentary on the UCC says nothing about your obligations when a vendor has multiple assignments. Those issues are resolved under common law, which means a lawyer has to figure out which state’s law applies.
An Authenticated Notice
Was the notice you got an ”authenticated” notice? The answer is that it depends on the facts of the situation. In the Louisiana case of Swift Energy v. Plemco-South (2015), a borrower and its factoring company emailed a customer. The customer’s employee told them to contact the customer’s proper office but didn’t sign and return the acknowledgment. The factor never followed up with that office and the customer paid the vendor. The court sided with the customer. It found that the email was not an authenticated notice because the notice did not go to the proper department when the lender knew which one it was.
Seasoned Legal Help
Independent counsel hired separately can review competing payment claims, who is entitled to payment, and any payment or response deadlines. Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company, not a law firm, so our role focuses on financial review and settlement negotiations. If your business is facing debt pressure of its own, contact us for a free and confidential consultation.








