A business debt settlement can resolve a creditor’s claims, but only if the creditor agrees and the agreement is properly documented. Although this may be a beneficial way to resolve your debt, you must ensure that the settlement puts the debt to rest. The creditor should specifically waive its rights to take further legal action against you and/or your business.
A Personal Guarantee
A personal guarantee is an agreement you make that says if the business defaults or doesn’t pay, you agree to be responsible for the obligation. If your business debts are signed with a personal guarantee, the creditor can sue you for a business debt that you were personally liable for as an individual. When you negotiate a settlement, independent counsel can check whether the agreement releases both individual (personal) and corporate liability and dismisses the claim against you. If you only have a document in place that waives the corporate liability and dismisses the claim against the company, that creditor may argue it can still collect against you personally. Also keep in mind that, generally, the FDCPA (Fair Debt Collection Practices Act) does not apply to collection activities for business debts. These laws protect only personal, family, and household debts (as opposed to business debts).
Negotiate a Settlement Even After a Creditor Has Filed Suit
You can negotiate a settlement even after a creditor has filed suit. As long as a lawsuit is active and pending, the creditor maintains the right to pursue action. We help track proposed payment terms and closeout documents. Independent counsel can review any required dismissal, release, judgment satisfaction, or lien filing before you accept terms. Many settlement agreements state that the dismissal will be with prejudice, which generally means the claim cannot be refiled. Some creditors will offer “dismissal without prejudice,” which would leave the business (or you) open to additional potential legal action because that dismissal is not a final settlement of the case. In federal court, if all the parties sign the dismissal, and the dismissal doesn’t say that you can’t refile, then that dismissal is without prejudice, and your creditor generally can refile the suit.
If the creditor already has a judgment against your business, the settlement should specifically outline what actions will be taken. Judgment settlement language should include provisions about satisfactions of judgments that will be filed with the court. If the written agreement leaves this type of determination to verbal conversation or handshake, there may be problems down the road.
In some settlement negotiations, you may negotiate an installment payment plan or other form of payment arrangement. When a settlement is in place and you do not abide by its terms, your creditor may pursue its claim against you. As such, you must be sure you can fulfill your obligations under the settlement. Some creditors might propose settlement agreements in which they will reserve the right to reinstate the entire original balance due in the event that you miss just one payment. Take a close look at your agreement to see if it has any grace period or has to give you written notice of default before enforcing payment in full. In New York State, a settlement agreement made while a lawsuit is pending can say that a judgment can be entered for a set amount without notice if you breach the agreement. If you don’t pay, the creditor must file the settlement agreement along with an affidavit saying you didn’t pay and a complaint or a short factual statement. The clerk must enter judgment.
To avoid disputes down the road, make sure that a creditor is agreeing to close an account in full satisfaction once the agreed upon amount is paid. If you just send a check marked “paid in full” and the creditor doesn’t agree to this, they might try to argue that you merely agreed to make partial payment on the debt. When you negotiate and reach a final agreement, get it documented in writing and signed by the creditor before you remit any payment. Never trust a verbal agreement with a company to settle a debt. A written document provides you with tangible evidence of the terms, and without it, you may have difficulty proving that your creditor agreed to waive its claim against your business. Retain copies of your signed settlement agreement, your transaction logs, the check you sent, any correspondence with the creditor’s office, and any post-settlement communications.
If you owe more than one creditor, settling with one may not address the debt owed to another creditor, even if that other creditor made the same or similar loan or loan guarantee to your business. If the only thing that has been negotiated is payment for the first creditor, you will remain liable for payment to the additional creditor. You will want to be sure that you have an agreement in place with all parties you owe funds to.
Settlement agreements often spell out how any ACH debits, levies, or notices to customers or a card processor will be handled once the agreed terms are met. Many also state that a UCC-3 termination will be filed within a certain number of days after your final payment.
When a Business Debt Is Cancelled
When a creditor forgives all or part of your debt, you may have to pay taxes on that amount. When a business debt is cancelled, the IRS generally treats it as income you received that year. As such, you might owe taxes on money you didn’t actually receive. Lenders are required by federal law to file a 1099-C report with the IRS if they canceled $600 or more of debt you owed. When a creditor settles for a payment of less than the entire debt, that creditor may be required to file a Form 1099-C for the difference. If the creditor keeps collecting after that, it may mean the debt hasn’t really been canceled. Merchant cash advances are often structured as purchases of receivables rather than as loans, and that can change the tax consequences. See a tax professional before year-end.
Also, closing or shutting down your business does not mean that your creditors won’t try to pursue legal action. If you have outstanding business obligations, a creditor may still seek to recover from your personal assets, even if your company no longer exists. What is more, often a personal guarantee, if you signed one, is triggered when you close your business. A small amount of money spent on a lawyer can go a long way.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we work with business owners in many states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.







