Business debt questions? A senior advisor replies in 30 minutes. Free, confidential.

Home / We Know Debt / We Know Debt · Updated October 10, 2026 · 4 min read

What Defenses Can an MCA Defense Attorney Raise in a Lawsuit in 2026?

What defenses can an MCA attorney assess in 2026? Learn how courts review reconciliation, repayment terms, and bankruptcy recourse in usury disputes.

Quick answer

Just because you signed a merchant cash advance agreement and failed to pay doesn’t mean you have no defense if you’re sued. One possible defense is that the cash advance isn’t really a sale of future receivables at all, but instead a disguised loan that is criminally usurious.

Written by Delancey Editorial · Updated October 10, 2026
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement firm, not a law firm. We negotiate with funders on your behalf and bring in independent attorneys only when a situation requires it. Attorney network access is determined case by case.
From the team that publishes thisCarrying business debt or MCAs? That's what we actually do.
Free review →
● Free review · 30-minute reply

Tell us about your MCAs. We'll tell you your options.

No costNo obligationConfidentialNo credit check

Your funders are never contacted without your OK.

$100M+
Business debt resolved
1,000+
Businesses helped
30min
Senior advisor reply
$0
Cost of the first call
In this article
Rather just talk to someone?
Key takeaways · Contracts to Purchase Future Receipts · LG Funding · Give Your Agreement to a Lawyer

Just because you signed a merchant cash advance agreement and failed to pay doesn’t mean you have no defense if you’re sued. One possible defense is that the cash advance isn’t really a sale of future receivables at all, but instead a disguised loan that is criminally usurious. That defense depends on the agreement’s specific terms. To see why, start with how these deals are built.

Contracts to Purchase Future Receipts

The criminal usury laws distinguish loans from genuine purchases of future receipts. The contract terms and how the arrangement works matter. Contracts to purchase future receipts are known as merchant cash advance agreements. The funder is supposed to be a purchaser of future receipts, and the merchant supposed to be a seller of future receipts. Not a lender, or borrower, as the case may be. The funder gives you money up front and gets it back (with a large fee) from your future receipts, electronically debited from your bank account. But the effective rate usually ends up being a lot higher than is permitted under our usury laws for loans, which is why whether this type of financing arrangement counts as a loan matters so much.

These types of agreements typically say that the provider is not a lender, describe possible payment adjustments when receipts fall (a reconciliation clause), and provide security for the payment obligations by obtaining a confession of judgment and personal guaranty from the merchant’s principal. No matter where the merchant is located, the agreements usually call for disputes to be litigated in New York, and as a result, the New York courts have had to consider many suits in which merchants have contended that the arrangements were in fact loans in the guise of sales.

So the core defense raised in many MCA cases is usury. That’s the “interest rate is too high” argument. It might get made if the funder sues the business. It might be raised in a motion to vacate a confession of judgment entered against the owner. It might be part of the business’s own lawsuit against the funder, under RICO or otherwise.

LG Funding

In March 2020, the Appellate Division, Second Department, decided LG Funding v. United Senior Properties of Olathe. LG Funding gave the merchant about $100,000 and the merchant promised to let LG Funding take $129,000 from its bank account. The merchant raised the defense of criminal usury in its answer to LG Funding’s complaint. So LG Funding moved for summary judgment dismissing the counterclaim and the affirmative defense. The court dismissed the counterclaim but allowed the affirmative defense to remain.

The court applied a simple test: unless the money advanced is repayable absolutely, the deal is not a loan. So how do you tell? Courts usually weigh three factors:

  • Does the deal have a reconciliation provision?
  • Does the deal have a finite term?
  • And does the funder have any recourse should the merchant declare bankruptcy?

In LG Funding, the reconciliation clause stated that the funder could, at the merchant’s request, change payments at “its sole discretion.” Moreover, the agreement stated that the merchant’s written admission of inability to pay, or the merchant’s bankruptcy, would be an event of default giving the funder the right to demand immediate full repayment of the unpaid purchase amount, enforce the owners’ personal guaranty, and enter a confession of judgment for the purchased amount. All of these provisions could be read to suggest that the funder did not assume the risk of low or no merchant revenue. This is a lawyer’s way of saying the funder didn’t have to assume the risk that sales would be disappointing or that they wouldn’t come in at all. Many MCA contracts contain similar language. An agreement with a definite end date, or one that allows the funder to recover in full if the merchant goes bankrupt due to a guaranty or confession of judgment, points toward a loan, and so does a reconciliation clause the funder can simply decline to apply; courts generally weigh these factors together.

The LG Funding decision came down when the Covid pandemic started, but the facts are from before Covid. The number of defaults under MCA agreements has likely spiked due to Covid, so this topic will be with us for a while. That is why the same three questions still frame the defense in 2026. These questions highlight terms courts have examined in merchant cash advance agreements:

  • Is the reconciliation clause mandatory, or does it merely give the funder an option?
  • Does the agreement expire?
  • Does the funder have collateral, such as personal guarantees or confessions of judgment, which protect it from the merchant’s insolvency?

Give Your Agreement to a Lawyer

The moral of the story for business people caught up in one of these disputes? Give your agreement to a lawyer. The language of the “reconciliation” provision, the length of the contract, and the security interest generally shape whether a usury claim is possible.

Where are you on the line?

Every MCA problem is on this timeline. Tap your spot.

Took the advanceDaily debits begin
Debits outrun salesSlow week, same pull
Took a second oneRenewal or new funder
Missed a paymentDefault notice, UCC
Something was filedCOJ or lawsuit
You're at: took a second one

Stacking is where most owners call us. It's also where negotiation does the most.

Two or more positions pulling from the same account. We review every advance and what one plan would look like, subject to each funder's agreement.

Review my positions →
HVAC technician in uniform outside a job
Who calls us

Contractors. Restaurants. Fleets. Shops. Owners who took an advance to keep working, and now the advance is the problem.

Daily debits, stacked positions, a notice in the mail. The first call is 15 minutes and costs nothing.

Get my free review →
The businesses behind the balances

This is who an MCA is sold to.

Auto mechanic in his garage
Auto repairTwo bays, one advance, daily debits
Restaurant owner at the pass
RestaurantsSlow Tuesday, same pull
Owner-operator beside his semi
TruckingEight trucks, three funders
Barber with a client
BarbersChairs rented, advance renewed
Baker at the oven
Bakeries4 a.m. start, 6 a.m. debit
Construction crew beside an excavator
ConstructionStacked to float a big job
Gym owner at her front door
GymsEquipment bought on an advance
● Business checking ··4827Masonry · Queens
Funder A · daily−$1,450
Funder B · daily−$1,225
Funder C · weekly−$6,800
After settlement · one plan−$4,100 /wk
Settled at 32¢ · 38¢ · 29¢ on the dollar over 14 months. Example outcome; results vary and require funder agreement.
What settlement looked like

Three funders. One line on the statement.

The owner kept the crews working the whole time. We handled the funders; where the case needed it, our attorney network handled the paperwork.

  • 68% total reduction across three positions
  • Business stayed open, no new advance taken
  • Dental practice, trucking fleet and restaurant group cases rotate here
See what mine would look like →
Delancey StreetSenior advisor · 15 min
Hi Marcus. Three positions, about $4K a day in debits. That right?
Yeah. Two with the same funder.
OK. Here's what a single plan usually looks like for that, and what it doesn't fix.
Do I need a lawyer?
Not yet. If that changes, we have attorneys. Let's look at the numbers first.
12:40 left · no documents needed
  • Minute 0

    A senior advisor calls you back

    Within 30 minutes during business hours. No intake script, no junior rep.

  • Minute 15

    You get a straight answer

    Whether settlement fits, what it involves, what it doesn't. Free, no obligation.

  • If you sign on

    We take the calls from your funders

    Proposed terms go to each funder, subject to their agreement. You stop fielding the calls.

What owners say

Thanks to the amazing team at Delancey Street, I am thrilled to share that I am now debt-free and my business is thriving. They successfully negotiated a great deal on my behalf while keeping me informed and updated every step of the way.

Tyler WilsonCEO, IT Services Company
Google reviews5-star rated
U.S. Chamber memberZogby rated
New York, NYNationwide clients
Forbes · Entrepreneur · NewsdayPress coverage
Straight answers

Questions owners ask before they call.

What does Delancey Street actually do?

We negotiate with your MCA funders to restructure or settle what you owe, subject to each funder's agreement. Not a law firm; attorney network when a case needs it.

Is a merchant cash advance a loan?

A true MCA is a purchase of future receivables, which is why usury limits often don't apply. Whether a specific agreement is really a loan is attorney work.

Do I qualify?

Most owners we work with carry $25,000 or more across one or more advances and have an operating business.

Will my funders be contacted without my permission?

No. Nothing goes to a funder until you've signed on and approved the approach.

What does the free review cost?

Nothing. Fifteen minutes, no documents, no obligation, no credit check.

Your question isn't here?

Ask a senior advisor. 212-210-1851, Mon–Fri 8a–7p ET, or leave your number and we call you.

Get my free review →
Last step

Done reading? Get your numbers reviewed.

Fifteen minutes with a senior advisor. Bring nothing. Decide afterward.

● Free review

One form. One call back.

Delancey Street is a business debt settlement firm, not a law firm. Attorney network access is determined case by case and only where a situation requires it.

Call nowGet free review
Call Now Get Free Help