Business owners who’ve given a personal guarantee often ask us: if the lender took a judgment against them, or if the lender didn’t, does that change their ability to settle? It seems like people think the judgment is the key. A federal case from Connecticut in 2018, Antonucci v. SBA, makes clear that the guarantee itself is what gives the lender its power, judgment or no judgment.
Richard Antonucci was the owner of two companies, Robrich Associates LLC and Annexed Used Cars Inc. In 2007, both companies co-borrowed $430,000 from Home Loan Investment Bank (HLIB). The loan was guaranteed up to 75% by the Small Business Administration (SBA). The business property served as collateral for the loan, and Antonucci also signed a personal guaranty. In other words, this loan was backed by a mortgage, a promissory note and a personal guaranty.
The guaranty Antonucci signed was unconditional. It guaranteed payment of all sums due under the note. It continued until the note was paid in full. He must pay when the lender demands in writing. The lender does not need to collect from any other source before coming to him. Read that language again. Under this guaranty, the lender could demand payment without first getting a judgment.
Then both companies defaulted. The business property was put into foreclosure in 2009, and after lengthy court proceedings it was eventually sold. The sale did not cover the amount the businesses owed to the bank. When SBA paid its 75% guarantee to the bank, it didn’t let his deficiency go away. SBA then followed up on the deficiency and pursued Antonucci personally through an administrative collection action rather than a lawsuit. Antonucci then received a notice from the Treasury Department’s Bureau of the Fiscal Service seeking an administrative wage garnishment on his paycheck.
Antonucci objected. His main point was that the court never entered any judgment for deficiency in the foreclosure case, and the SBA had already paid the bank for its guarantee. Oh, and, apparently, the property was valued wrong and his payments were applied wrong to the loan account. These arguments concerned how the debt and guarantee were treated. Court outcomes depend on the facts and applicable law.
A hearing officer rejected the deficiency judgment argument. The hearing officer found that neither the SBA nor the lender was required to obtain a deficiency judgment before pursuing a guarantor. Antonucci then appealed to the U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut. The SBA and Treasury asked the court to dismiss or grant summary judgment. The court granted summary judgment against him. In doing so, the court emphasized that a guarantor’s personal obligation comes from the guaranty, not the court’s judgment.
The court agreed with the hearing officer: when an SBA loan defaults, the SBA steps in, pays on its guarantee and buys the loan debt from the lender. The SBA has the right to collect from everyone obligated on the loan, including the guarantors. The SBA guarantee protects the lender; it does not in any way reduce what the borrower or the guarantors owe. Why does it work this way? Because the SBA is repaying 75% to 85% of the loan to the lender, so the lender can use that money to lend to other small businesses. In return, the SBA generally requires an unlimited, unconditional personal guaranty, on a standard form, Form 148, with the same language as Antonucci’s. The same kind of guaranty is used by conventional commercial lenders.
Explore Settlement
So, back to the settlement question. Technically the judgment does not make a guarantor liable, it’s the guarantee that makes the guarantor liable. In Antonucci there was no judgment of deficiency, but the wage garnishment was upheld nonetheless. Independent counsel can assess possible defenses. Enforceability depends on the agreement and applicable law. What does that mean for you, if you are the one who signed the guarantee? Negotiating a settlement with the lender or the SBA may be an option, subject to its agreement and independent legal review. So don’t confuse the judgment with the tool that powers the collection. Negotiating a reduction depends on your finances and the creditor’s agreement. Find out how much money you do have, and what options are open to you. Explore settlement.
The Antonucci case also highlights why cash flow and borrowing costs matter when assessing a growth strategy. A qualified financial professional can help assess affordability. Owners under financial pressure may consider financing with higher costs. Terms vary by lender. Some financing is available quickly. Payments that exceed available cash flow can increase default risk. Some business loans require a personal guaranty. If it defaults, the collectors go after the owner personally. A loan guarantee can expose the owner to personal collection claims. Independent counsel can explain that risk before signing.
Know how much power a personal guaranty gives the lender, and get a good lawyer before you sign and when the collection starts to understand the agreement and any collection claims.








