What happens when you have both factoring and MCA funding against the same receivables? Factoring uses an assignable interest in each specific account. MCA often uses an interest in all accounts, attaching to revenue as it arrives. Under Article 9 of the UCC, the first to properly file a financing statement generally has priority, even though factoring of an invoice is usually regarded as a sale, rather than a loan. The contracts you signed with each are probably as crucial here as the order in which the papers are filed. For instance, many merchant cash advance contracts call selling receivables to a factor without their consent a default. So, read both contracts carefully.
The overlap starts because trucking brokers and shippers pay on 30, 45 or 60 day terms. You need cash for fuel, insurance, driver pay and maintenance now. A factor advances most of an invoice in a day or two, and the broker pays the factor when the bill is due. An unexpected big repair or slow month will send you to the MCA lender, who always seems able to offer the fastest funds in a crisis. Both lenders are working off of the same receivables, and their claims often conflict.
Almost all factors file UCC-1 forms on the invoices they buy. The filing lasts five years unless renewed. Many MCA lenders file also. These often describe “all accounts, receivables and proceeds” of the business. Some name all business assets.
Takes Priority
A factor’s claim against the invoice is often a senior interest, but priority generally depends on who filed first and on the agreements between the parties. An MCA company who attaches later to a broker’s receivables may have an interest against little or nothing, since most of the cash will already have been paid directly to the factor. If the MCA lender got there first, the factor’s UCC search should show that. A cautious buyer of invoices will demand a subordination or intercreditor agreement with the MCA before it will purchase an invoice. A factor typically runs a lien search before advancing money. An MCA company taking blanket interests is likely to have filed and show up on a UCC search. You can run the same search for yourself by business name.
Once a broker gets written notice that a bill is assigned, that bill generally is discharged only if paid directly to the assignee. Paying the trucker generally no longer discharges the bill. A notice requesting partial payment raises legal questions that independent counsel can review promptly. Sometimes, however, the buyer fails to answer the broker’s request for reasonable proof of assignment in time, and when the broker then pays the carrier the bill is generally discharged. MCA lenders can send such notices, too, after default, or sooner if the contract allows. The carrier’s customers may find themselves being asked to pay another party.
Default has real teeth: the MCA company usually can insist on the full remaining balance right away, and call brokers listed in its UCC filing. In some cases a funder will have taken a “confession of judgment” from the business owner or principals. Sometimes, the problem works in the other direction, too: many factoring contracts require that the factor have the first lien on the collateral. So, signing an MCA agreement after the factoring contract may itself breach the factoring agreement. Wording varies a lot by contract. Not every funding combination is a default for another, but examine your contracts carefully before a funder or factor surprises you.
Even if all the papers fit together on paper, the math often does not. One lender takes a cut of every load you run; the other takes a flat rate out of the account you’re supposed to run your business from. There’s little left after paying each lender’s cut. The squeeze leads to a second or third advance. You may be able to ask your lender for a true-up based on what is actually in your account. Look for what’s called a “reconciliation” clause.
If you are already in this situation, pull out every contract with the funders and every Uniform Commercial Code filing. Pay special attention to who filed first and exactly how each of them describe the collateral. Look for clauses on selling receivables or seeking additional financing. Changes in how receivables are handled can affect contractual obligations and creditor rights. Independent counsel can explain those obligations; any proposed changes require the necessary parties’ agreement.
Some factors are used to working with an MCA lender. Sometimes, they agree to take certain invoices, leaving the other funder free to make an advance on the balance of the receivables. Independent counsel can review the written terms and any signing requirements.
If you are getting squeezed by an MCA payment you cannot afford, discuss your financial records and proposed payment terms with your lender; negotiations alone do not change payment obligations. Also, advances on top of an advance often don’t provide much more capital, and they often make the collateral fights and debits worse. Another cash advance to cover the first two can add costs and payment pressure.
The UCC filing follows the loan. When the MCA is paid off, the business generally needs to send the lender a written demand to end the UCC filing to trigger the lender’s duty to terminate it. It is then required to file, or deliver to you, a termination statement within 20 days. If you settle instead, a settlement usually results in some taxable income from forgiven debt, unless an exclusion like insolvency applies.
If your funder has sent notices to your brokers, or your bank account is frozen or a judgment has been entered, bring the notices and court papers to independent counsel promptly. That review calls for a qualified business debt lawyer.
While the whole mess can be confusing, prevention can be simple: before you sign a contract with a second lender, ask three questions of each of them: what type of collateral their UCC filings will describe, whether their contract allows for this other product, and whether they would sign a subordination or intercreditor agreement if there is an overlap. Unclear answers leave issues for independent counsel to review.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: negotiate proposed debt settlement terms with creditors, subject to their agreement. We are based in New York. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








