How Companies Structure Their People
Four common examples of a chain of command structure in a small company are the traditional top-down pyramid, the flat open-door model, the inverted pyramid, and cross-functional teams with a lead plus a backup. A clear chain of command says who reports to whom and who approves what.
A chain of command is the unbroken line of authority linking every person to one manager. That is called unity of command, because everyone should only report to one boss. In a small company, the structure points toward the owner, but you don’t manage every role. The steps along the way show who approves what, and who evaluates whose work. Any structure that keeps confusion to a minimum is the right setup for you.
The term chain of command comes from the military. In military command, the leader says what the goal is, subordinate officers translate that into tactics, and the troops do as they’re told. That kind of chain works in business, too. The trick to running one in a small company is to simplify down to what is essential.
Any confusion about responsibilities is costly. Gallup reports that only one in two employees “strongly agree” that they know what is expected of them at work. This uncertainty leads to disengagement and missed targets. You can’t hit a target if you don’t know what it is. It’s also difficult to aim for a target if you can’t see what the boss is shooting for. In a small shop, one missed goal can be a big missed goal.
The traditional pyramid chain of command is the most familiar version. When you see an org chart, this is the model in the picture. The owner or CEO is at the top, and individual contributors fill the base of the pyramid. In between is a layer of middle managers. The middle manager bridges the gap between the daily tasks on one side and the strategic goals of the whole company on the other side.
The traditional chain of command is the most common way to organize people. Strategy flows down from the top. When the top person sets a goal, all the layers figure out their part in it, and each team comes up with a plan to achieve it. Even a small company has overall goals, which get translated to team objectives that individual team members contribute to. Things come down the chain, and other things go up the chain. Reporting, new ideas and problems go up the chain. It may start with an employee or a middle manager, but each step along the way has to have the authority to approve or reject the request. That way, nobody duplicates work or lets a task fall through the cracks.
The drawbacks of a traditional chain of command grow from its strength. The rigid division of authority and responsibility can get stuffy and slow. How many steps is it from a customer’s call to your ears? If you choose a pyramid structure, let your managers know you encourage all customer feedback and all suggestions for improvements. Otherwise, an old-school chain of command can become an information filter that isolates you from the marketplace. If you group people by function, such as sales, IT and finance, each function may become a silo, with little sharing across department lines.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce offers that when companies have between 10 and 50 employees, each manager should have no more than eight direct reports. That’s a starting point, not a rule.
The most basic and pure example of an open-door chain of command is the one without any middle managers. Each staff person reports straight to the founders, and that’s it. If you keep the head count low, that keeps the command structure simple. In a small shop, it’s easy to talk to everyone, so problems get solved with a quick chat. Nobody has to wait on multiple sign-offs to go buy a few shelves or order business cards. On the Shopify Masters podcast, Natalie Westlake, president of Bluboho, a jewelry brand, says the company has “quite a flat structure” and “an open-door policy.” This structure lets her hear feedback immediately.
In an inverted pyramid, the frontline staff is on top: the people who talk to shoppers, pack shipments and make marketing content. The manager is not “above” them; rather, the manager is “below” them as a coach and a support role to give the tools and budget to respond to what’s happening. It flips the order on its head, and it doesn’t mean there’s no boss. It means that the primary job of the boss is to support the staff. The trick to the flipped pyramid is to train your managers to ask the right questions. Always ask how much budget or which software would make the work go faster. What do you need to do the work? It’s not micromanaging, and it’s not abdicating. Curry Hagerty, CEO of Hart Jewelry, described it on Shopify Masters: “Our job is not to tell them what to do.”
In cross-functional teams with a lead plus a backup, titles matter less, because the work is what matters. One person is the lead, and the other is the backup. When a staff member doesn’t show, another steps in to cover. The pairing should be between skills that are different, but connected. For example, the marketing lead might work with the supply chain manager. Lexi Hensler, cofounder of the weighted stuffed animal brand Hugz, told Shopify Masters that each role has a leader, “but there’s always a support listed with that person.”
Circular and network structures have their fans, but they lack a clear chain of command. When everyone is on an equal level, it’s less clear who makes key decisions. Any new hire may not know who can approve a big change. One matrix structure comes from having one manager for what each person does, and another manager for what each person works on, like a software manager and a product manager. It’s complicated, because each person works for two bosses.
Business Officers
The board of directors manages a Delaware corporation, but it can have one member: you, the owner. The bylaws or the directors set the officer titles and duties. One person can hold several offices, unless the charter or bylaws say otherwise.
If you file as a manager-managed LLC, then acting managers can commit the company to contracts and agreements. The California Corporation Code says a member of a manager-managed LLC acting only as a member cannot bind the LLC. A manager can bind the LLC. New York is similar, unless the operating agreement or a manager gives that member authority. Delaware is the most liberal. Both members and managers can bind the LLC, unless the operating agreement says otherwise.
The U.S. Supreme Court set a narrow rule on who counts as a “supervisor” under the Title VII civil rights act. A ‘supervisor’ is someone empowered to take tangible employment actions, such as hiring, firing, or demotion, according to Vance v. Ball State (2013). The federal Title VII and ADA civil rights laws cover private employers with 15 or more employees for at least 20 weeks in the current year or the past year. State laws may cover smaller companies, too, so it helps to be clear about who has the right to hire and fire and who makes those decisions.
If you miss payroll tax payments, you may have to pay a penalty called the trust fund recovery penalty. The IRS can charge a person 100% of the unpaid trust fund tax if the IRS finds the person was responsible for the tax and willfully failed to collect or pay it. Besides owners and directors, the agency may collect from officers, employees or a payroll provider. IRS guidance says that a non-owner employee who only paid bills as a superior told them to, and didn’t make any choices about which creditors got paid, generally isn’t a responsible person.
In a small company, one person may make most of the choices about where cash goes. If you’re in a company, write down what every role does. Also, put in writing who decides which bills get paid first. Those records may come in handy if the IRS says one of the business officers should have to pay a penalty. Any person proposed for the trust fund recovery penalty has 60 days from the letter to appeal if the letter went to a U.S. address, and longer if it went abroad.
The Top of a Chain of Command
Most of the time, the person at the top of a chain of command is the CEO or president. When private investors hold shares, the CEO usually reports to the board of directors, which are shareholders’ elected representatives. In an owner-run small business, it’s common for the founder to be the top manager. Keep the owner on top in an owner-run business. That way, everyone knows who makes the decisions.
If the headcount stays small, a flat or lead-plus-backup structure may be the simplest choice. When the number grows, a traditional pyramid offers clarity about who does what. The best structure has two features. First, every role has a boss. Second, every decision has an owner. Each person knows whose work to look at and who looks at theirs. Pick a structure and try it out. Write out who reports to whom and approves what, and remember who decides what to do first when bills are due.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you negotiate proposed debt settlement terms with funders. Based out of New York, we can discuss whether our services fit your business. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








