Business owners facing financial distress have options before creditors can force their hand, including negotiation outside of bankruptcy (a workout), installment programs for taxes and SBA debt, the sale of assets or equity, and a formal bankruptcy filing for reorganization, whether under Chapter 11 (for most businesses) or under Subchapter V. Whether it makes sense to sell your inventory or take another of these routes, the right course of action for you will depend on your goals and your leverage. For some businesses, an orderly wind down outside of court may be most efficient.
Waiting carries risks. First, the bank can repossess its collateral. Typically, lenders can take equipment if repossession can happen without any “breach of the peace.” This can involve disabling equipment or selling it on the premises.
Collection of tax or SBA debt often begins with a longer series of notices than collection by private creditors, but the IRS can levy bank accounts and the Treasury can offset federal payments without first getting a court judgment. A creditor holding a tax claim like the IRS typically has to send written notice about an upcoming levy at least 30 days beforehand, and requesting a hearing within those 30 days can pause enforcement, allowing time to gather information and negotiate or otherwise deal with it. SBA COVID EIDL loans 120 days delinquent may be referred to the Treasury Offset Program.
Out-of-court Workout
The first option is an out-of-court workout, where you and your creditors negotiate privately and informally to repay debts on modified terms. This is most common when the business has relatively few creditors and is still viable.
Taxes and Small Business Administration debt have their own programs. The IRS has a Simple Payment Plan for payroll taxes if you owe $25,000 or less (including penalties and interest) and are up-to-date on filings and payments. With the IRS, the traditional offer in compromise process requires a $205 application fee, but it can be waived for low-income individuals (not for entities). Monthly payments on SBA COVID EIDL loans can be cut 50% for six months if a business is current and less than 90 days overdue, and interest keeps accruing.
Creditors may decline proposed terms. If they refuse to agree to negotiate terms you can handle, the next options may be to sell the business, sell an equity stake, or close it. Selling the business or certain assets might be a way to deal with current debts and raise funds for continuing operations. Of course, a sale is not without drawbacks. When assets are sold, the business no longer owns them. And where owners sell equity in a business, their ownership is diluted or they may lose control.
Restructure Debts and Start Fresh
When the informal process breaks down, bankruptcy court can offer a chance for a business to restructure debts and start fresh (reorganization). As soon as a bankruptcy is filed, the automatic stay generally kicks in, subject to exceptions. It can pause lawsuits and other creditor actions. Starting a chapter 11 filing can provide the most robust protections for businesses, but it is expensive and time-consuming. Filing for bankruptcy can help, but it comes with costs, time, and public disclosure.
A streamlined process called Subchapter V for many small business can allow for reorganization in bankruptcy, after the usual automatic stay stops creditor actions, but at a faster pace and lower cost than a traditional chapter 11. Only one reorganization plan, prepared by the debtor, may be proposed, which a business must file within 90 days of filing unless the court extends. A subchapter V reorganization plan (written plan for repayment) for a business may be confirmed over the objections of creditors only if “fair and equitable,” that is, all of the business’s projected disposable income is paid in the plan for at least 3 years. Federal court filing fees for chapter 11 cost $1,738 and start the process.
You can harm your options by picking which creditors to pay before you file. A trustee may go back ninety days, or one year for payments to insiders, to recover payments on old debt that let a creditor get more than it would in a chapter 7 case, if the debtor was insolvent when the payments were made. A trustee generally cannot claw back payments made in the ordinary course of business, though that exception has specific requirements.
Permanently Wind Down the Business
A distressed company may have no choice but to liquidate, or permanently wind down the business. Maybe an assignment for the benefit of creditors (ABC). Under state law, it lets an owner direct assets to a trustee outside of bankruptcy to sell and distribute to creditors. This can cut the cost of ending things over chapter 11.
The lender may try to get a receivership. But first the lender must file a lawsuit to get a receivership. A receivership is likely cheaper for a lender than bankruptcy, and debtors do not gain the protection of the automatic stay. The biggest drawback of a receivership for a debtor is losing control of the business to a receiver.
So which option will work for you? Every business has its own story. What should guide you is what you want to end up with, both personally and business-wise, and what leverage you have with creditors. Personal liability and legal risks also vary by option. A business’s cash on hand can help it steer the process. When a senior lender is owed more than all the assets are worth, they are more likely to steer. Before agreeing to any deal a creditor proposes, compare it with what you would get and risk if you didn’t take it. A qualified tax professional or independent counsel can confirm the applicable filing requirements, eligibility, and deadlines for your situation. Gather the relevant financial records before that review.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you negotiate proposed debt settlement terms with funders. Based out of New York, we can discuss whether our services fit your business. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.