It’s not unusual to discover new debt, either because you didn’t include all your debts when you enrolled in your program or because you took on new debt after enrollment. Before you find out if that new debt can be included, you need to know what type of debt consolidation you signed up for. That’s because there are two different types, and they operate very differently from each other.
Consolidation Through a New Account
One is consolidation through a new account. This is where you take out a debt consolidation loan, credit card balance transfer, home equity loan, or home equity line of credit. The new lender pays off the accounts you listed on your application, and consolidates all of those accounts into one new account. A consolidation loan is a one-time thing. If a bill shows up in three months, you can’t go back to the lender and say ‘look, remember this stuff you handled for me? I need you to pay this.’ It doesn’t work that way. So the loan does not pay it off, and you will have to pay that debt separately, in addition to the new loan.
This also applies if you inadvertently underreported the balance on a debt at the time of application. For anything that was not paid off, the balance carries on the old account and continues to accumulate, and in the case of a home equity loan or line of credit, you are required to continue to pay the old debts until they have been paid off.
New debt can also come from your own cards. When you take out a loan or do a balance transfer on your cards you do not have to give up and cancel your cards. Any further card use creates additional debt and remains subject to the account terms. Consumers who use cards again after consolidation may rebuild their balances. So now you have the credit card payments, plus the consolidation loan payment. New charges can offset the benefit of consolidation.
A new consolidation loan would require a separate application and review. Even though you might have received a “pre-approved” offer, there is no guarantee that you’ll qualify. The new lender may balk at the amount of debt you already have or a missed or late payment on your report. If you have stopped paying the bill in anticipation of the loan, you could also be hit with late fees. And a failed attempt to open a new account may negatively impact your score.
Then there’s the new loan, which adds another expense to the mix. Transfer, application or processing fees are typical with balance transfers, home equity loans and lines of credit. With a balance transfer it is common to pay 5% of the amount transferred, so every $1,000 transferred costs $50. A qualified financial professional can help compare the total cost and risks of a new loan or balance transfer.
Payment Consolidation
The second type of debt consolidation is payment consolidation, using a debt management plan through a nonprofit credit counseling agency. No debts are transferred. Instead, you make a single monthly payment to the agency and it distributes the money to your creditors on your behalf. Eligible unsecured debts may be included in one monthly payment, depending on the agency’s rules and each creditor’s agreement.
Plans may cover certain unsecured debts, such as credit cards or medical bills; eligibility varies by agency, debt type and creditor. The agency can confirm whether a hospital bill or phone bill in collections is eligible. Any minimum or maximum balance depends on the program.
Your first move is to call your credit counseling agency and see whether they can work the debt in. The new creditor will not always offer the same concessions as the other creditors on your plan (ex: lower interest rate, waive late fees). It’s not your plan that decides this but the creditor. The counselor at the agency is the best person to speak with. Meanwhile, make sure to pay the new bill in a timely fashion. You don’t want to end up with the account in collections.
Debt management plans commonly restrict new charges on enrolled cards. These accounts are generally closed to new charges after the creditors agree to the plan, as the goal of the plan is to eliminate the balances, not increase them. Repayment time and results depend on the balances, agreed terms and payments made.
For people on a debt management program, the credit stuff isn’t as scary as most people think. FICO notes that participation in a credit counseling debt management plan is not a factor considered in the calculation of a consumer’s FICO score. The closing of accounts that are not maxed out can lower your credit score, but the effect often lessens as you reduce the balances on the cards.
If a new debt is added, the payment amount and monthly fee both may go up. Monthly fees and any legal caps vary by program and state. The agency can provide its fee schedule, and independent counsel can explain applicable limits.
How the Debtor Manages Their Debts Afterward
In the end, the outcome of any debt consolidation plan relies on how the debtor manages their debts afterward. As the amount of debt decreases, credit scores generally go up. A new debt is a setback, not a defeat. Learn what kind of debt consolidation program you are enrolled in and deal with the new bill the appropriate way.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners. Our goal is simple: negotiate proposed debt settlement terms with funders, subject to their agreement. We are based out of New York. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.







