Should you try an out-of-court workout, or file Subchapter V? The workout avoids the paperwork, deadlines and cost of a court filing. But it only works if all the creditors cooperate. Even one holdout can bring the process down. A Subchapter V case has an automatic stay against collection, and your plan can be confirmed by the court even if creditors don’t vote for it. But the case will be supervised by a trustee, and it needs to be done in strict adherence to all the court’s deadlines.
At its core, the decision is this: can you ride it out? If you have a good working relationship with your creditors, they believe that you can (not will) repay them, and you believe that there are no creditors who would balk, then maybe a workout is your best option. But if you find yourself saying “should” rather than “will,” then probably that trust isn’t there, and it may be time to ask independent bankruptcy counsel whether to file Chapter 11 (likely Subchapter V) instead.
Under Subchapter V
The first question to ask is whether the business can qualify for Subchapter V. Subchapter V caps debt to $3,424,000 on the filing date. That limit is calculated by combining all the debtor’s debt that is not contingent (its existence is certain) or unliquidated (its amount is not certain). The debtor also has to show that at least half of the total noncontingent, liquidated debt came from business operations, not from personal or consumer transactions. An initial increase to $7,500,000 expired June 2024. The Senate passed H.R. 7730 on September 28, 2026 to restore the $7.5 million limit, but the bill was not yet sent to the President.
A main reason to file is to stop collection efforts. That’s what the automatic stay protects. It prevents creditors from filing new lawsuits to collect pre-bankruptcy debt. It stops already-filed lawsuits. It also prevents creditors from exercising setoff rights on property of the debtor (such as freezing a bank account held at the same bank). The stay arises when the petition is filed and pauses many different kinds of disputes, but not all. In an out-of-court workout, a debtor would be protected by nothing more than the good faith of each creditor.
By its terms, the Bankruptcy Code allows a debtor to confirm a plan of reorganization without the approval of any creditors. The debtor instead can propose plan terms that are ”fair and equitable” to each class of creditors, which means the debtor devotes all ”projected disposable income” to be received over a 3-5 year plan term. If the plan meets that test and the other confirmation rules, then it can be confirmed even if creditors would not vote for it. A creditor can vote against a Chapter 11 plan, but if it’s confirmed over the vote (called a ”cramdown”), the creditor is bound by the terms of the plan and it cannot look to a Subchapter V debtor for any payments other than those the plan requires.
In Subchapter V, the debtor usually remains in possession of the business while the plan is proposed and confirmed. When you try to retain ownership of your business in Chapter 11, you sometimes rely on an exception to the ”absolute priority rule,” by which senior creditors are entitled to be paid before the owners keep their equity. In a Subchapter V case, if the plan pays unsecured creditors an amount equal to the debtor’s projected disposable income over the plan term, the absolute priority rule does not work the same way. This means that the debtor may keep equity in the business even if creditors are not paid in full.
Under Subchapter V, the debtor can receive a discharge after the court confirms the plan even without creditors voting for it. It comes only after you complete payments due in the first 3 years or the longer period the court sets. If the court set 5 years, that’s how long you wait. But even then debts listed in section 523(a), and any plan payments due after the deadline, stay with you.
The filing fee for Chapter 11 cases is $1,167, plus a separate administrative fee. However, unlike traditional Chapter 11 cases, a Subchapter V debtor does not have to pay quarterly fees to the United States Trustee Program. A trustee is appointed in every case. A creditors’ committee can only be appointed in Subchapter V for cause, and the debtor is not required to prepare a disclosure statement before filing a plan of reorganization unless the court orders it.
A Subchapter V plan must be confirmed by order of the bankruptcy court. In Subchapter V, you have deadlines from the beginning. A status conference is generally scheduled within 60 days after you file. The debtor report is due at least 14 days before that meeting. It’s on the prospects for a consensual plan. Only the debtor can file a plan in Subchapter V, and it is due within 90 days after filing, unless that time is extended for reasons not within the debtor’s control. Failure to meet these deadlines, or failure to appear for hearings, exposes the debtor to loss of control over the case.
A Realistic View of the Impact on You
A decision about your company should take into account a realistic view of the impact on you. If you have personally guaranteed business debt, then whether your business survives in its current form may not be much comfort to you. The guarantor does not automatically get relief under the business’s plan, and the guarantor is not part of the business’s bankruptcy. You will need to find a way to get relief, and you may have several options. Sometimes a negotiation with the creditor will be enough. In other cases, you may need to file your own individual bankruptcy.
Your taxes are affected too: debt settlement that is not part of a bankruptcy is generally taxable, unless an exclusion applies. Lenders will report canceled debt on Form 1099-C if they write off $600 or more. Debt discharged in bankruptcy is generally excluded from income. The excluded amount is claimed on Form 982.
Prepare to Choose a Path
When you believe that trouble is coming, you should try to preserve all available options for yourself. Every day spent using limited resources reduces your options. As you prepare to choose a path, make sure that your financial records are as complete as possible. This includes having up-to-date financial statements, copies of tax returns, bank records, a list of receivables, a list of payables aging, information about lien holders and lessors, payroll, and a cash-flow forecast. A Subchapter V plan has to be feasible, which means that the projections of income and expenditures have to be accurate and believable. If the numbers aren’t solid, or if the business or personal finances aren’t in order, then the plan may not be confirmed.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we can help in most states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.