You signed a personal guarantee on a merchant cash advance, and you’re falling behind. You can’t pay, and you’re thinking you’re going to lose your house and your car. That’s not the whole truth, but it’s part of it. The scope of your guarantee depends on its terms and applicable law. Independent counsel can explain the potential exposure to your personal assets. That exposure can matter if you default. But there are options, both before a default and after one. Here is how it works, and what we tell the owners we talk to at Delancey Street.
Merchant cash advances don’t work the way the name sounds. The “advance” is generally structured as a purchase of receivables. In this arrangement, the funder buys an amount (the “Purchased Amount”) of the company’s future sales or receivables at a discount, for a lump sum of cash (the “Purchase Price”). The funder collects the money it’s bought through ACH withdrawals from the company’s bank account, usually daily or weekly. When the owner personally guarantees the company’s performance, the funder can generally pursue both the business and the owner’s personal assets in the event of a default, subject to the guarantee’s terms and legal exemptions.
Event of Default
So you’re late on your Merchant Cash Advance and you don’t see how it’s possible to catch up. If you read the agreement you signed, you’ve probably noticed that falling behind is not the only way to cause an Event of Default, though most of the others are variations on that same theme. Blocking the funder’s debit to your account, for example. So is having more than a set number of debits bounce for insufficient funds within a set period. Closing or changing your bank account without letting the funder know. Opening another account without letting the funder know. There’s more. (Stacking can also be considered an Event of Default, and the funder usually imposes a penalty for doing so.)
If you defaulted on an MCA, it can get crazy, and pretty ugly, too. The funder can file and/or enforce its UCC lien against covered business assets, including customer receivables, sometimes without a lawsuit, subject to the agreement and applicable law. It can sue you in state or federal court for breach of contract and breach of the personal guarantee. It can do both at once. Common symptoms: Customers start telling you they got a letter from the funder telling them to send their payments to the funder rather than to you; you receive a summons and complaint in the mail, or you don’t even get a summons, but rather your bank account gets frozen.
Don’t just ignore the summons. If you don’t answer it, you may wake up to a judgment against your business and against you personally. Another thing: forum shopping. If the agreement contains a forum-selection clause, the funder can often file the lawsuit in the state the contract names, such as New York, even if you’ve never been there, even if the deal never happened there. It’s a sign that it’s time to call a lawyer.
Owners start panicking when they get a personal guarantee in connection with an MCA. But here is the part that matters most. Many MCA guarantees are written to cover the performance of the business. An MCA is supposed to be repaid only to the extent that the business makes revenues, unlike a loan, which must be repaid regardless of how the business performs. In a true merchant cash advance, the funder generally takes the risk of losing its money if the business dissolves, closes shop or files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, unless the merchant breached the agreement. A lack of receivables does not by itself establish that the advance is no longer owed. In a true MCA, if your customers don’t pay you, you don’t get paid and the funder generally doesn’t get paid either, unless the agreement was breached; changes to the payment amount usually go through the agreement’s reconciliation process.
Ask Your Funder for a Reconciliation and an Adjustment
If you’re struggling with payments to an MCA, there’s something you can try before you default. Ask your funder for a Reconciliation and an Adjustment. Adjustment reduces the daily or weekly payment amount to reflect a downturn in the business. A Reconciliation (sometimes called a “true-up”) means you ask the funder to return the money over-collected. If you can’t make the payment because you aren’t getting enough revenue, go to the funder and show them the proof. Do not wait until you are in default to talk to the funder.
Is an MCA a loan? If you are in New York, that can be the question. New York’s criminal usury law caps interest at 25% a year. Most MCAs earn far more than 25% when annualized. According to the funders, an MCA isn’t a loan so that there can be no interest and hence no usury. Some courts accept that. Usury can still come into play, though, if the funder acts like a lender, refuses to lower your payments, or fixes the terms of the agreement. But even if a funder’s deal is legal, a merchant may still have claims if the funder breaches the terms of the agreement, or commits fraud or some other wrongdoing.
When something goes wrong in an MCA, it can really go wrong. Your funder might keep the original terms of your advance even after you call and ask for a lower payment and a reconciliation, for example. Regulators have accused some funders of debiting merchants’ bank accounts for the same amount multiple times. Regulators have also accused some funders of collecting more than the Purchased Amount. Keep written records of any offers for additional financing and their conditions. Keep track of all of this.
Settle for Less than the Full Balance
A funder may agree to settle for less than what you owe; starting negotiations does not change payment obligations. The lender, of course, would like the terms to favor it, and most owners have no idea what they are supposed to ask for in a settlement agreement. Your interests need to come first.
At Delancey Street, we are not a law firm, and we are not a lender. We’re a business debt settlement company, and our senior advisors negotiate with your MCA funder to settle for less than the full balance. We won’t try to sell you another loan. For questions about litigation or bankruptcy, we can suggest speaking with an independent attorney. Our first consultation is free and confidential, and we can discuss the costs of our settlement services on the first call.