Yes, it is possible to settle the loan when a lawsuit is filed. Assuming you still have sufficient funds (assets/liquid income) to enable you to settle, it is still not too late. Even if a judgment has been taken against you for the full amount of the debt, you still have the opportunity to negotiate. Most litigation is settled prior to trial, but the process can be protracted nonetheless. Legal costs can affect a lender’s willingness to settle. Timing alone does not determine the outcome.
A personal guarantee makes you personally liable for the business debt if the business is unable to repay. Closing or dissolving the company has no effect on your personal guarantee. If the business declares bankruptcy and its debt is discharged, the personal guarantors will continue to be liable. If you have personally guaranteed a business loan, personal assets may be at risk, depending on the guarantee and applicable law; independent counsel can explain your exposure.
Ideally, you’ll have available a qualified lawyer to help you determine what your best course of action would be in replying to a lawsuit. In most jurisdictions, the deadline to respond to a complaint is roughly 20 to 30 days after service, typically by filing an answer. Missing the applicable response deadline can lead to a default judgment.
The rationale for a settlement on a personal guarantee is similar to that of a commercial loan workout: business sense. When it comes to litigation there is a threshold where a smaller settlement is preferable to the costs associated with continued litigation. The bank is aware of its internal costs, and when those costs outweigh the expected recovery, it may consider a settlement.
A judgment gives a lender legal avenues to collect against your assets. It does not guarantee that the assets will exist, will be worth as much as you think they’re worth, or that they’re within the lender’s grasp. Collecting on a judgment is a whole different ball of wax from obtaining a judgment.
After a judgment, a creditor can send a writ of execution, or can take additional discovery about your finances. The federal consumer credit protection act generally limits ordinary wage garnishment to the lesser of 25% of disposable earnings or the amount above a protected earnings threshold; other limits and exceptions may apply.
After a judgment has been rendered, however, the lender has more leverage. Keep records, respond on time, and bring judgment notices to independent counsel promptly. A California judgment, for instance, can last for 10 years and be renewed again and again against a business.
A guarantee that does not exist, or that is legally defective, may not be legally enforceable, and in that situation a guarantor may contest enforcement rather than settle. A lawsuit is burdensome and expensive. In a contested case, the defendant’s attorney generally answers the complaint, files discovery, conducts depositions and other methods of fact-finding, and prepares the case; unless the matter settles, it ends up in court where the judge makes a ruling.
If you contest the enforcement of the personal guarantee but lose the case, you may end up with more to pay. In New York the judgment interest rate is 9% a year on business debt. California judgments against a business accrue interest at 10% a year. And it keeps growing at that rate until paid in full, so contesting just to fight another day can be more expensive in the long run.
For example, if the court enters judgment for $100,000 against you on a business debt, the interest added each year would be:
| State | Annual judgment interest rate | Interest added per year | | New York (business debt) | 9% | $9,000 | | California (judgment against a business) | 10% | $10,000 |
Negotiate a Personal Guarantee
If the matter has progressed to the point where the lender has named you in litigation and, perhaps, has even obtained a judgment, you should still get as much paperwork together as possible. And you should do so at the outset. To negotiate a personal guarantee you’ll need all of the court papers, a copy of the personal guarantee, and the loan agreement. You’ll also need to prepare an honest financial statement detailing your current assets, liabilities, income, and expenditures. Lenders verify information. Independent counsel can advise on any acknowledgment of the debt; settlement discussions should use accurate financial information. There is often room to negotiate; lenders commonly start with a higher number.
While it is generally a good idea to be forthright about your current financial situation, statements made during negotiations can sometimes come back to haunt a guarantor later. Federal Rule of Evidence 408 and most state versions generally keep settlement talks out of evidence, but the protection has limits and some statements fall outside it.
There is no universal formula to calculate how much you should offer to settle. Every creditor may weigh differently the age of the debt, your proven inability to pay, the strength of its legal case against you, the cost of continuing to collect, and its best estimate of the chance you’ll file bankruptcy. Settlement negotiations often involve a series of offers of increasing amounts.
If you do reach agreement, make sure it is in writing and signed by the lender’s representative. A settlement agreement typically includes the exact amount to be paid, the payment schedule (all at once or a series of monthly installments), and a release of the business and the guarantor personally from liability under the guarantee. And when a lawsuit is pending, the agreement is typically accompanied by dismissal of the lawsuit or the satisfaction of the judgment; settlement talks alone do not stop the case.
Obtaining a valid release is also an important part of any settlement. Just getting the business’s debt settled doesn’t mean the bank can’t chase the guarantor. A partial release is only good for the portion settled, leaving the personal guarantor on hook for the unpaid amount. Release wording can also be narrow or vague; the lender may allow that it releases you from claims that are the subject of the settlement, but that they are preserving their rights on claims not included in the deal. Settlements of secured debt also commonly provide that the lender sends UCC terminations to remove the lien from the public record.
Be sure to make all the payments on time under a payment-plan settlement, because a default typically revives the balance in full. And in California, once you’ve satisfied the debt (with payment or a settlement), the creditor has to file a form (EJ-100) confirming that you’ve satisfied the judgment. There may be a penalty for not filing the satisfaction of judgment within 15 days of your request in writing.
SBA loans differ from other commercial loans in that the agency generally has to send the debt to Treasury after 180 days delinquent, with some exceptions, such as debts in litigation. If SBA offered to settle, it would have to be on the ground that they thought the debt was not collectible (because you don’t have the ability to pay), because the costs of collection would not justify the value of what they could collect, or because litigation was too risky. Settlement with SBA over inability to pay would usually need a financial statement signed under penalty of perjury. Debts owed to the federal government also differ in collection: the agency can garnish up to 15% of your disposable pay without any court order, after at least 30 days’ written notice.
Personal Bankruptcy Filing
Filing a petition in bankruptcy court automatically stays (stops) lawsuits against the person who filed the bankruptcy petition, even ones started before filing, with some exceptions. Chapter 7 stays most lawsuits and most wage garnishments. The stay needs no court order, and it is automatic when you file.
But if the only bankruptcy petitioner is your business, then the business’s discharge does not end your personal liability as its guarantor. The Chapter 13 codebtor stay (which protects consumer cosigners) doesn’t apply to business debt. To discharge personal debt as a guarantor, the guarantor generally has to file bankruptcy in their own name; a business’s bankruptcy does not discharge the owner’s guarantee. Subchapter V of Chapter 11, created for small businesses under a debt limit, may give the company a streamlined way to restructure and keep operating. But on its own it does not end your guarantee.
Chapter 7 can free a person (not a corporation) from most debts, with a lot of exceptions. It leaves liens on property. Chapter 13 bankruptcy, which can discharge many obligations, is generally available only to individuals with regular income whose noncontingent, liquidated unsecured debts are less than $526,700 and secured debts are less than $1,580,125 (limits effective April 1, 2025, and adjusted every three years).
Because bankruptcy deals with many creditors in a single proceeding, it is often considered when there are multiple creditors or lawsuits on several fronts. When there is only one lender and cash for a realistic offer, settling is often faster, cheaper, and more private than bankruptcy. If bankruptcy is a realistic possibility, it can cap a lender’s worst-case recovery, and that can affect the lender’s position in settlement negotiations.
Keep in mind the tax implications. If you have debt forgiven as part of the settlement, then the IRS generally treats the forgiven debt as taxable ordinary income. Canceled debt can generally be excluded from income to the extent the debtor was insolvent immediately before the debt was canceled. Debt canceled in a personal bankruptcy case is generally not taxable income, although the exclusion can reduce certain tax attributes. If the discharged amount is significant, then consult with a tax professional before you move forward.
A Commercial Debt Lawyer
You can negotiate alone, but a commercial debt lawyer may be most useful when a personal guarantee is in play and the creditor has sued you. An experienced lawyer can spot leverage, draft terms for you to offer the lender, and negotiate for you.
Have a lawyer check if your guarantee is enforceable. Assume nothing. Legal fees, court costs, and the danger of losing can be significant if the debt is big. Weigh those costs against what you might pay to settle now.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: negotiate proposed business debt settlements with creditors. Based out of New York, we help business owners explore settlement options. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








