If you own a business drowning in merchant cash advance debt, you have two main options for tackling your debt problem – hiring a debt settlement company or filing for bankruptcy with a lawyer’s help. If daily withdrawals and lawsuits are already crushing your cash flow, talk to a bankruptcy attorney early. Settlement only works when creditors agree to a deal, and if you’re already at the point of financial disaster, it may be too late for that. Waiting too long narrows your options.
A Debt Settlement Is Not a Guarantee
Neither banks nor private lenders are required to negotiate with debt settlement companies. On top of that, a debt settlement is not a guarantee that collection calls and lawsuits will stop. The agreement only applies to those creditors you settle with. During the payment period you may still be getting calls and you may still be sued if a creditor is unwilling to wait. If you’re sued, the creditor might win a judgment, and then garnish your wages or put a lien on your home.
Debt settlement can leave you deeper in debt than when you started because your unpaid debt continues to accrue interest charges, fees, and penalties. As for the company’s fees, under the Federal Trade Commission’s rules, you don’t pay a fee until at least one debt is settled, you’ve agreed on a settlement with the creditor, and you’ve made a payment to the creditor. If you end the agreement, the company has to give you back the money in your account, minus the fees it’s earned, within seven business days.
Bankruptcy’s Super Power
For small businesses the automatic stay is bankruptcy’s super power. The filing automatically stops most lawsuits, judgments, collection efforts, foreclosures and repossessions – and no creditor has to agree. (Debts incurred after filing don’t qualify.) Compared to debt settlement, this is a major advantage. You don’t have to worry if a creditor won’t deal with the settlement company. Nor can a funder continue to drain your account by ACH withdrawal. That gives the business breathing room to stabilize.
Which chapter you file under still matters, though. In Chapter 7, a business in the form of a corporation or partnership gets no discharge at all. Chapter 13 is for people, not businesses, and only works if you get regular income – and it caps unsecured debt at $526,700 plus a separate cap for secured debt.
Subchapter V of Chapter 11 – the Small Business Reorganization Act (SBRA) created it to cut the time and administrative burden of Chapter 11. It puts the owner in control and shortens the timeline. A business must file its plan within 90 days unless the court extends it for reasons not its fault. This keeps everyone focused. On cost, the court filing fee is $1,738 for Chapter 11, versus $338 for Chapter 7 and $313 for Chapter 13. Subchapter V has a debt limit too. Congress passed a bill in September to raise that limit to $7.5 million, but as of October 14, the President has not signed it.
The “Catch-22” of MCA Debt
MCA debt strangles merchants with fixed daily or weekly payments whether their revenue is up or down. The ”Catch-22” of MCA debt can induce a small business owner to borrow more money just to try and cover those fixed payments. The frequent borrowing worsens the problem and makes it harder to stop the cycle.
States have usury caps to prevent loan companies from overcharging desperate borrowers. These caps usually don’t apply to MCAs because the agreements are written as purchases of future receivables, not loans. Courts are increasingly looking past the label. In the Shoot the Moon case the court held the transactions were nothing more than loans disguised as sales, and the trustee recovered over $1.1 million of payments made before bankruptcy as preferential transfers. When a court treats an MCA as a loan, the legal rules that apply to loans may come into play.
A personal guaranty – where the business owner pledges to be liable for the debt if the business doesn’t repay it – is not erased just because the business files Chapter 11. Early intervention also can create leverage to address personal guaranties. A qualified tax professional or independent counsel can confirm the applicable filing requirements, eligibility, and deadlines for your situation. Gather the relevant financial records before that review.
While a bankruptcy appears on a credit report for up to 10 years, settled collection accounts generally appear for 7. There’s a tax catch to settlement deals. The IRS generally treats debt forgiven in a settlement as taxable income, while debt discharged in bankruptcy can be excluded (Form 982). Check with an accountant or tax preparer on how much your forgiven debt will cost you in taxes.
Debt settlement might seem like the easier choice. But court supervision and protection combined with a legal restructuring process may work better for your situation. Talking to a lawyer may give you more options than you expect.
Timing is critical. If you act early, you may have more options and more leverage with creditors. Delaying only lets more debt stack up as the MCAs compound. Filing bankruptcy is not failure but a chance for a structured path forward.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we work with business owners in many states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








