So what happens if you default on an SBA loan? It’s not as if small business owners want to stop paying their bills. But things can get bad. The business can close down and the owners have to walk away. In those cases, even if they want to pay off their loan, they may simply not be able to do so. Luckily, SBA has a program for borrowers who do not want to file bankruptcy and instead just want to make a good faith effort and settle with the lender. It is called an Offer in Compromise.
After you default on your SBA loan several things happen. First the creditor liquidates the borrower, which in almost all cases is the company who received the financing. The liquidation happens in order to try and recover as much of the defaulted balance as possible. After the borrower is fully liquidated then the creditor begins to chase down the guarantors. In most cases the guarantor is the individual who signed for the loan, although sometimes friends and family are also guarantors.
In addition, with SBA loans the guarantors are jointly and severally liable. This means that while you all are liable for the same total balance, each guarantor is considered individually as a full source of reimbursement for the entire balance. With five guarantors, for example, you cannot assume that you each owe 20%. Rather, each guarantor is liable for 100% of the balance. The SBA will chase down whoever they think has the most money or is easiest to collect from.
How Much the Creditor Thinks You Are Worth
How little can you settle a defaulted SBA loan for? That’s never a simple question, for one thing because settling the debt has to be handled very delicately. The short answer is that you can generally settle a debt for as little as the lender would get from you if it were forced to collect the debt. There are a number of factors that go into how much the creditor thinks you are worth to them. The four that matter most are the value of current assets, your earning potential, cooperation and character, and the cost of collection.
The first of those is the easiest to calculate: the value of the current assets you’re holding. Add up the current value of all your major assets (home equity, cash in the bank, cars, investment property, etc) and subtract all the secured debt against those assets. That’s the current equity in your assets. Note that in some cases the law protects certain assets from creditors: for example, homestead exemptions, retirement accounts, college savings and wage garnishment rules.
But don’t expect to get away with zero just because your assets are inaccessible. The SBA OIC is a privilege, not a right. Remember, you’re working in good faith with your banker to avoid the high cost and stress of bankruptcy or litigation. Let’s say you live in Texas, so the home is protected by a homestead law. It’s worth 500,000 dollars and there is no mortgage. In this situation, it’s unlikely that the bank will forgive 250,000 dollars of defaulted debt for pennies on the dollar. While the equity may be off-limits to the creditor, they are unlikely to let you off the hook when you can clearly pay in full. What if the debt was 800,000 dollars and you couldn’t refinance the full amount of equity in the home? At that point, you could likely negotiate for less than what is owed.
Factor 2: Future earning potential. This is always going to be part of the negotiation for SBA Offer in Compromise, but the calculation is a lot more vague. What it comes down to is the creditor looking at your current earnings and employment, your history of earnings, your age and health and from there making some sort of determination about what it could get from you through, say, a wage garnishment. Protections at the state level can lower the “garnishment risk”, particularly if you’re a head of household with many dependents.
Keep two things in mind about garnishment. First, garnishment is generally taken off gross pay, after the mandatory deductions of social security, Medicare and the federal income tax, but before health insurance, 401k or any other voluntary deduction. Second, garnishment is a long, slow process that costs the creditor money. So if you can scrape up a lump sum to settle for, you can often get away with a much lower amount than the garnishment would collect, since cash today is so much more valuable to the creditor than cash tomorrow.
The third factor is cooperation and character. This factor is possibly the most important in determining whether the Offer in Compromise will be accepted and at what amount. As part of liquidating the business and evaluating the guarantor’s finances, the creditor will ask for and expect your cooperation and participation. Having an appraisal of the assets of the business performed, and providing financial statements may be a good way to show your intent to help the creditor get as much as they can in recovery. This will be an important factor in negotiations. Many people who ignored their creditors until they got sued have a much more difficult time getting the best offer possible.
Factor 4: The cost of collection. That’s what the creditor would have to pay to legally collect the money it is owed. Every step it takes to collect, from mailing a default notice to foreclosing on your home, costs the creditor time and money. The longer the collection process goes on, the more prohibitive the cost can become. That means the creditor has an incentive to accept a smaller amount right now instead of collecting the full balance through the legal collection process.
Documentation is key to getting the best possible offer. The SBA requests only two standard forms: SBA Form 770 and Form 1150, as well as two years’ worth of tax filings. But to get the best offer, you should provide plenty of other documentation. Ideally, every number, every fact, every item you present to the creditor should have a third-party document to back it up. For instance, if you have a mortgage balance listed on the personal financial statement (SBA Form 770), include the most recent mortgage statement to show where you got that number. And most importantly, provide a well-crafted hardship letter.
Let’s review what happens after you default on an SBA loan: First the business is liquidated, then the creditor looks for money from the guarantors. A settlement, or Offer in Compromise, is a negotiation - not a formality. Any offer has to be couched in terms of what the creditor could reasonably expect to collect from you through forced collection. Be cooperative, document, and don’t give your creditors the silent treatment.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a premier, and award winning, business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we can help in 49 of 50 states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








