When your company can’t pay its bills, bankruptcy looks like it offers legal protection from creditors and a chance to wipe out some or all of the debt. Well, that’s not quite the way it works. For a business, bankruptcy can be (how to say this nicely) less than helpful. It also comes with hidden costs, some of which may surprise you. That is especially true when a corporation or LLC files Chapter 7.
Picture your company as a suitcase. Your business has assets and a bank account, and customers owe it money. As the owner, you get to open the suitcase and see what is inside. You can use it to pay the bills. You can also take things out and sell them. When a business files bankruptcy, the owner can expect to lose control of the business. Because Chapter 7 is a liquidation, a Chapter 7 trustee is appointed by the court. After the filing, the bankruptcy court takes the suitcase and you lose control. The Chapter 7 trustee will open the company’s suitcase and pull out a variety of things. The stuff in the business that’s worth money is transferred to the trustee.
First, your corporation gets no discharge in a Chapter 7. A person who files does, but your corporation doesn’t. A discharge is when a judge says you no longer owe a creditor. Wait, what? You mean bankruptcy isn’t a reset button? If I file, I still owe money? Yes. And that’s not the only unpleasant surprise.
Once it has the suitcase, the trustee’s first order of business is whether to sell the company as a whole, suitcase and contents. This almost never happens. Huh? How can this be? Why doesn’t the trustee just sell the company? Because usually there is no business to sell. Either it is failing, or it relies on the owner to appear everyday. Take him or her away, and the business will close - just like that.
So the trustee does what it generally can. Chapter 7 is for selling stuff. Most corporate bankruptcies simply involve taking the company’s assets and trying to sell them for as much money as possible. The proceeds are split among creditors pro rata. Then it will give you back the company. Which is still in debt. Still yours, yes. But when the trustee is done with the company’s suitcase, there is nothing in it. And it will not do you any good. Companies in this position filed to get a court-ordered liquidation. But they live on with their unpaid debts.
And then there is that little matter of all the costs in the middle. I’m not just talking about all the time, hassle and complication. I’m talking about money too. Paying a lawyer to tell you how to liquidate the company costs less than paying the lawyer to take it through Chapter 7. What you should be thinking is “how much will it cost me to wind down the company and close the doors for good?”
Things look different if you are a sole proprietor, or if you personally guaranteed the company’s debts. Then personal bankruptcy is often the better route. Chapter 7 discharges people from all of their debts, and then they can start over. But remember, you are filing as an individual - that’s you, not the business. And that means that the Trustee gets to choose what to do with the business if it is part of your filing. Will the Trustee sell it as a going concern? Yes if there is a buyer, but most often there is not. Will the Trustee sell off the company’s assets? Not if it owes more than it owns because then its creditors would get paid first.
So why would a company ever file Chapter 7? When creditors accuse the owner of fraud, transferring control of the business to the Chapter 7 trustee is a way to show that the owner did not steal the business’s assets. Furthermore, the filing of the bankruptcy decreases the likelihood of a successful claim for the owner’s liability for debts of a corporation or limited liability company. Nonetheless, a Chapter 7 for a corporation or LLC rarely makes sense.
Chapter 11 Rules for Small Businesses
Chapter 11 is another story. For a long time, Chapter 11 wasn’t a good choice for a small business owner. However, revisions to the Chapter 11 rules for small businesses took effect in February 2020 (Subchapter V) and the option is now viable, and often a better choice than Chapter 7. In particular, it can make sense for a business to file bankruptcy if it will help them get their major creditor or creditors to treat them better. For example, it will give you time. Time to ride out whatever caused the trouble in the first place.
Bankruptcy isn’t always the best idea for a business. Sometimes, it is the worst. A company that files a Chapter 7 does not get a discharge of its debts. There is usually no business to sell. It is usually cheaper to liquidate a business without a Chapter 7 bankruptcy than with one. The hidden costs of bankruptcy are many, and they may include the loss of your business. Don’t do it without knowing what you are signing up for. Whatever you decide to do with your business, remember, you have options. None of them are free, but you can figure out what is best for you.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a premier, and award winning, business debt settlement company that helps business owners nationwide. Our goal is simple: help you escape debt in a safe and legal manner. Based out of New York, we can help in 49 of 50 states. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.