A commercial tenant’s default puts both landlord and tenant in a bind. The tenant has to decide whether to move out, stay and fight or sue, and the landlord has to decide whether to evict, renegotiate or sue.
Emotions run high for both sides. The parties may disagree about property conditions and responsibility for the dispute. The landlord may also face financial losses.
This analysis is not exhaustive. Rather, it sketches a general overview of the remedies and rights of both parties.
An unguaranteed tenant who goes broke and defaults may simply wind up the company or file a corporate bankruptcy (unless its claims against the landlord look good). The landlord often gets the space back relatively quickly, but unpaid.
Closure does not necessarily end either side’s obligations or claims.
Personal Guaranty
The typical commercial lease makes the owner sign a personal guaranty. Because the guarantor is usually a person or entity with assets of its own, the tenant generally can’t just walk away. Instead it has two basic options.
The tenant can discuss proposed terms with the landlord while keeping records and responding to notices on time.
Early discussions may help clarify each side’s position. An early deal can let the tenant wind down the business in a controlled way, help the landlord cut its loss by getting the space back into productive use, and reduce litigation costs for both sides.
Because commercial lease terms often favor the landlord, early bargaining can help keep losses down. An early settlement, if the landlord agrees to one, can allow the tenant to avoid a large judgment. Sadly, early deals often don’t happen, and not just because of high emotion.
Most landlords list their losses, add them up and hand the tenant (or its guarantors) a large bill. These landlords believe they are entitled to whatever recovery the lease promises. And as a matter of law, they may be.
Different expectations about recovery can make early agreement difficult. The result is often a long lawsuit that uses up scarce resources for everyone.
Fighting Is a Gamble
Once suit is filed, both sides usually hire lawyers (business entities generally must appear in court through one), and the costs start to add up. Attorneys’ fees pile onto losses that have already been felt, and emotions are at their height.
Litigation outcomes are uncertain for both sides. Independent counsel can assess potential liability and the consequences of a judgment.
Filing suit does not rule out later negotiations. Many tenants don’t realize that if the landlord wins and the lease has an attorney’s fees clause, the judgment can cover the landlord’s costs of the lawsuit (attorney’s fees) on top of unpaid rent and other damages.
Claims about lease violations and any defenses depend on the evidence and applicable law. Interest and legal costs may increase while a case continues. A tenant facing a lawsuit can bring court papers to independent counsel promptly.
A judgment does not guarantee collection. Collection depends on available assets and lawful enforcement procedures.
Winning a Judgment Is One Thing, Collecting It Quite Another
A landlord’s ability to obtain a judgment depends on the lease, evidence and applicable law. Recovery of costs, fees and damages depends on the lease and applicable law. (Independent counsel can review the lease’s terms.) The amount of any judgment depends on the court’s findings.
Even when a landlord wins, winning a judgment is one thing, collecting it quite another.
A tenant’s response to a lawsuit depends on the facts and legal advice from independent counsel. Responding to a lawsuit does not establish who will win or the amount of any judgment.
Both parties need to preserve relevant records and respond to notices on time. A guarantee raises separate questions about personal liability.
Independent counsel can assess concerns about asset transfers and collection rights. Delays do not establish misconduct; court papers and deadlines still need prompt attention.
Attempts to hide assets or hinder collection can create additional legal risks. Collection may continue despite delay or settlement discussions. Delay alone does not release a debtor from a judgment.
Settlement proposals require creditor agreement. Claims involving transfers or piercing the corporate veil have distinct legal requirements. Independent counsel can review each side’s rights and obligations.
There is no single moral of the story; the ending depends on the choices the tenant and landlord make. After a default, payment obligations and legal deadlines remain important. Negotiations do not suspend those obligations or deadlines.
Each decision point in the process deserves careful thought, and a better understanding of what lies ahead. Independent counsel can help assess decisions about a particular dispute.
About Delancey Street
Delancey Street is a business debt settlement company that helps business owners. Our goal is simple: help you negotiate proposed settlement terms with creditors, subject to their agreement. We are based in New York. We tell you how it is; because your business and future is on the line.








